3 ms·
Call me skeptical. Virtually everyone who has spent more than a few years programming can attest that it has, at the very least, opened a new dimension of logic
by danso 13y ago
Call me skeptical. Virtually everyone who has spent more than a few years programming can attest that it has, at the very least, opened a new dimension of logical thinking and problem-solving that is not easily found in other fields. I think the challenge of creating an interface to this kind of thinking that is friendly to non-coders is difficult enough...but the idea that once these tools are made, they'll grok what to do? Hmmm...We're much closer to a future where machine readers can read all manner of text out loud, but does that mean there's little use for teaching literacy?
edit: Here's an example - I recently got done teaching a data basics class, and inevitably, my students ran into the problem of data typing in Excel...you type in something like "9/14" into a field, and it treats it like a date, and moreover, displays it as "Sep-14". But when you try to concatenate the field, or perform some other kind of operation on it that is not date-related, Excel treats it as an integer (number of days since 1904, or something like that).
So Microsoft has arguably done something user-friendly here...virtually anyone who types in '9/14' probably means September 14, 2013. However, this isn't always the case, and if it isn't, you have to know how to format columns in Excel as text. Moreover, the operations upon date types are not at all intuitive. If you've done a minimal level of programming, you get the idea of data types, including dates and strings. Let's pretend Microsoft comes up with a way to perfectly guess what you mean when you've typed in a value...is it possible this will eliminate the need for the average user to have an understanding of data types in order to do non-trivial work?
- stelonix 13y agoThere are many ways to mitigate these issues. The one I like to believe will be the most used would be a entire new way of using computers. Just like Google uses complex algorithms in order to try to give you better search results, I see no reason why Excel can't try to "learn" your usage. I'm quite saddened that it's 2013 and few applications try to learn more about the user's usage patterns.
- ben336 13y agoOveraggressive learning algorithms can in some cases be more annoying than well thought out defaults. Especially since they won't be consistent (at least at first). Its not an easy thing to do right. For things like spreadsheet formatting, you want to have consistent behavior that you can rely on.
- jiggy2011 13y agoI guess the difference is that what google does is already somewhat fuzzy, when you search for something you're not necessarily even sure what you want the search engine to return. We also don't expect the results to necessarily be perfect which is why the search engine returns more than one result. On the other hand when you're trying to do some specific task you already know in most cases exactly what you want to happen, so if it does something else then that is very frustrating.
- stelonix 13y agoWell, that's the trade off I'm hoping people are willing to make. Just like we did it for search back when Google was new, for example: we had to learn how to use Google compared to whichever search engine we were using before. It's just like trying to learn a new application. I do believe unless the whole computing system/environment works in this new paradigm, the effort wouldn't have as much impact as I'm picturing in my mind.
- jiggy2011 13y agoGoogle is good for searching immensely vast troves of information simply because there is no other way you could really do it. A categorical index of the entire internet would be fairly un-feasible. OTOH when we have smaller and more focused collections of information such as programming documentation or catalogues of similar products we tend to find it easier to navigate with categorical listings or simpler search algorithms.
- takluyver 13y agoI've heard this idea encapsulated in a neat phrase: 'Control interfaces should not be intelligent'. I think I first read that after Wolfram Alpha was launched.
- jpea 13y agoBuild a system with what seems to be a good, logical set of usage assumptions and you will find that once it's out in the wild, you will get people trying all kinds of different ways of using your system. It defies your own logic, but humans aren't that logical (usually). Being too clever with your assumptions usually backfires.
- nly 13y agoUs humans are insanely proficient in adapting to weirdness and suboptimal environments, and plain retarded when it comes to coping when others mess with what we're used to. Classic example: the QWERTY keyboard. If you want to do a fun experiment, try and watch the pain in two subjects faces. One who has never used predictive text trying to use it for the first time, and one who has used it for years and is trying to use an old phone without it. Now imagine a scenario where every predictive text implementation had tailored itself to the user.
- CmonDev 13y agoThe Excel rule is simple: if you want an expression then start it with '='.