4 ms·
I like that in this version you ignore the problem of what happens to BitCoin when no one spends it and everyone just hordes it.
by XorNot 13y ago
I like that in this version you ignore the problem of what happens to BitCoin when no one spends it and everyone just hordes it.
- snitko 13y agoThat is a very important question. Because it is so often asked when talking about Bitcoin, I took some time to write an answer for it. Please read it and let me know if you have questions: http://snitko.ru/blog/the-beauty-of-deflation.html http://snitko.ru/blog/the-beauty-of-deflation.html
- kybernetikos 13y agoThat's a problem if it's your economys main currency. If the aim for BitCoin is as the worlds second currency, then that's not so serious, as long as the volatility is not so high that people are reluctant to take it in payment.
- snitko 13y agoIt's not a problem even if your economy only has Bitcoin. Deflation is not a problem.
- kybernetikos 13y agoI know you think that because I read your blog post, however the limited amount of knowledge I have on the subject suggests that it can be a pretty bad problem. Deflation is regressive - it harms those who need to spend the most and leads to concentration of capital at the expense of labour. It punishes those with debt, which will make it difficult for normal people to ever acquire large capital goods e.g. a house (by the way your argument that lenders won't mind negative interest rates because their final value is worth more than what they started with is wrong because it doesn't take into account opportunity cost - lenders compare the returns not against the current value of their holdings, but against their other options e.g. putting the money in a hole). It reduces the velocity of money and therefore economic output. You say that at least it redirects it to the areas that are most important, which may be true, but nevertheless, it shrinks the pie from which we all partake, and reduces the rate of growth, a problem in a world with a growing population. Bitcoin would also suffer from similar problems to gold in that in bad economic times, all the capital needed to recover would flee the regions suffering, making any recovery much more difficult.
- snitko 13y agoWith an inflationary currency all those wonderful things you describe that allegedly help recovery are actually done at the expense of those who save. When you say "deflation punishes those who are in debt" I raise you "inflation punishes those, who save". Now why do you believe being in debt is somehow more noble than saving? I beg to disagree. Also, remember, borrowers, if they really need to borrow, may decide to only borrow from those who account for estimated deflation, so that they would be able to pay back. It's just an accounting trick really. Deflation only punishes unsmart people who mindlessly seek for deals that don't account for the changes in the economy. Inflation punishes people who didn't want any kind of deal and simply had their money saved somewhere. > It reduces the velocity of money and therefore economic output You would have to explain how exactly this happens. Output != value. If you dig holes or build cars no one buys you increase output, but you don't add value to the economy.
- kybernetikos 13y agoThere's a lot that can be said on this topic (I'm even tempted to make the argument that borrowing is indeed, in most cases, more noble than saving), but I just want to pick you up on one point. When you say 'save', it's not clear whether you're talking about hoarding (where the money is no longer doing anything useful in the economy) or investing (where the money is still part of the economy). Inflation doesn't punish those whose savings are invested, in fact it rewards them, it does however punish those whose savings are hoarded.
- snitko 13y agoI talk about hoarding and there's nothing wrong with that. If you want a new house or a new car, I think saving money until you have enough is a much nobler way to do it. When you say that "money should work and do something useful in the economy" what you're actually saying is that they should work "now". Hoarder's money will work just the same when he decides to spend them. Thus, what you have to discuss here is not hoarding, but rather "spending now" vs "spending later". Why do you think the former is superior to the latter?
- 13y ago
- Jach 13y ago"Ignore"? Maybe I didn't ignore that particular failure mode, but didn't ever consider it? Or I was going to mention it but forgot? Or have considered it before and concluded it's not worth reexamining, hence it wouldn't occur to me to reconsider it for my comment? The third option is the case here. I didn't think about it again for my comment and then decide to ignore it. A better verb would be "omit". But let's briefly reexamine it again... What does happen to bitcoin if no one spends it? Well it probably goes to a value of $0. Is this a hard inference? That makes your comment kind of reduce to "you ignored the problem of what happens if bitcoin dies." If it dies, your coins are worthless. Duh? In reality we see people are spending bitcoins so there is presently some sort of incentive to spend, so maybe the problem isn't the lack of incentive to spend itself, but whatever causes that lack of incentive to spend in the first place, and that cause cannot be currently at work because currently there is incentive to spend. So the cause cannot merely be "deflation", as that's already happening. A future cause could be hyper-deflation, but then I'll ask you what happens to the USD in hyper-inflation... A more general thing to look at is the incentive to use bitcoin and ask whether bitcoin is useful. Bitcoin is more than just a currency, it's also a set of tools for making transactions. If bitcoin isn't useful, there's no incentive to spend or hoard it. Presently I think bitcoin is useful; bitcoin has the pretty cool feature of being able to pseudonymously send an arbitrary amount of money from anywhere in the world to anywhere else in the world, instantly, without reliance on a single third party. And the stuff highlighted on https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Contracts https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Contracts and elsewhere for future applications that the core infrastructure is more or less ready to handle is very cool. And there are items or experiences one can acquire with bitcoin that are difficult to acquire with traditional currencies and financial systems. All of these features are subject to competition. The US government could make drugs and online gambling legal and vendors could make such items and experiences easy to acquire with USD, Visa et al. could stop charging their array of fees (at least with bitcoin the only fees are small not-percentage-based transaction fees and currency exchange fees that are typically less than credit card processing percentages), PayPal could get better, etc. The many ways in which bitcoin could die due to better competition make that threat much more interesting and plausible to consider and wonder whether bitcoin could keep up or would die immediately as the case would be for "what if it dies because no one spends it anymore?". Edit: Admittedly a more interesting question can be "what's likely for the future of bitcoin when considering the ratio between people who find bitcoin useful for its features vs. people who just find it useful as a way to get more USD?" If this was what you really meant to highlight, I'm sorry for misinterpreting.