3 ms·
I'm not sure we should expect them to be now. If you really believe this, then your response should not be to ask the government to pass laws forcing such comp
by pdonis 13y ago
I'm not sure we should expect them to be now.
If you really believe this, then your response should not be to ask the government to pass laws forcing such companies to be "rational". Your response should be to start a "rational" company that out-competes them, by hiring all the talented people that can't get jobs at the bigoted company, and thereby drive the bigoted company out of business.
- silencio 13y agoTech is full of companies that basically do what Tim Cook and Apple wants everyone else to do. Yet we still have a problem. And no amount of publicity blasting discrimination in any form seems to make a difference - sometimes it even does worse by calling all the trolls and bigots to attack the victim(s) involved. So no, that doesn't really work, does it now. I find it depressing that I have to bundle this industry into the same basket as other companies and industries that other women complain about on the female-dominated forums I frequent. Meritocracy? hahahahahahahaha
- pdonis 13y agono amount of publicity blasting discrimination in any form seems to make a difference Have you considered not doing business with companies whose hiring or employment practices you don't like? Or forming your own company to out-compete them?
- icambron 13y agoAgain, do you actually believe that the widespread discrimination against pre-civil rights blacks was rational behavior? If not, why did it persist for so long? Where were all of those entrepreneurs fixing the system through competitive advantage? I think the answer here is that the advantages it confers aren't sufficient to allow an upstart to overcome its disadvantage--namely, market position. Having more rational hiring practices is not a trump card. Lots of poorly run companies beat well-run ones all the time, but it doesn't mean they wouldn't be more successful as better-run companies. I'll also note that there are a number of confounding factors that make non-discrimination more attractive when enforced corrosively. For example, let's say you're an industry with widespread discrimination against gay people. Gay people leave the industry, and are thus not readily available to those willing to hire them. And perhaps they're typically less experienced because of that discrimination, so that makes it less useful to hire them. A sort of tragedy of the commons in the labor market. It's still irrational to discriminate, just less so, and perhaps the disadvantages of doing so fit under the noise floor. But with legislation, the feedback loop works the other way, and it makes a lot more sense to hire from this now larger and more experienced labor pool. Could increase the overall output a lot more than having one company float to the top through marginally better hiring.
- tsotha 13y ago>Again, do you actually believe that the widespread discrimination against pre-civil rights blacks was rational behavior? It absolutely was, because at that time in much of the country if you hired a black guy all his coworkers would refuse to work with him. White people would refuse to patronize your business.
- djur 13y agoWhich is why state intervention was required to change the norms in place.
- pdonis 13y agoWhere were all of those entrepreneurs fixing the system through competitive advantage? They were prevented from doing so by government regulations--state and local government regulations.