23 ms·
This isn't an issue that the invisible hand is going to fix. Then why is the WSJ article titled "Workplace Equality Is Good For Business?" Shouldn't it be titl
by pdonis 13y ago
This isn't an issue that the invisible hand is going to fix.
Then why is the WSJ article titled "Workplace Equality Is Good For Business?" Shouldn't it be titled "Workplace Equality Is Good, But We Need To Force Businesses To Do It By Law"?
- potatolicious 13y agoThis assumes the invisible hand is fully rational and capable of the optimal decision making - at the very least at an aggregate scale. It is possible for something to be good for business, but for the free market to not choose it. The free market, after all, is simply a collection of human participants, none of whom are perfectly informed nor perfectly rational. There seems to be a weird belief in some circles that the free market tends to arrive naturally upon a globally optimal solution.
- pdonis 13y agoThere seems to be a weird belief in some circles that the free market tends to arrive naturally upon a globally optimal solution. There is a much more widespread weird belief that governments can do so, even though the track record of governments is worse than the track record of free markets.
- potatolicious 13y agoMuch more widespread? Last I checked nobody is advocating for Soviet-style central planning. In fact by far the most popular notion in the western world is a mostly-free market with some regulation. Which seems to jive with the notion that neither a monolithically planned, nor entirely laissez-faire system, are likely to produce optimal results.
- pdonis 13y agothe most popular notion in the western world is a mostly-free market with some regulation No, the most popular notion in the western world is a nominal "free market" with massive regulation. For example, here are the rules that a "free market" business in the US has to abide by: https://www.federalregister.gov/ https://www.federalregister.gov/ Note that this is a daily journal: in other words, the "current issue" is just the rules that got issued today. Not to mention that we have central control of the financial system (the Fed and other countries' central banks), education (in the US there is at least some control still at the local level, other developed countries control everything at the state or national level), and trade--here, for example, is the current list of US tariffs: http://hts.usitc.gov/ http://hts.usitc.gov/
- djur 13y agoAnd the rules that got issued today include several announcements by the Coast Guard about changes to drawbridge schedules, species being delisted from the Endangered Species Act, and announced decisions by the FAA on the airworthiness of various products. Business is moderately regulated in the US, especially compared to other industrialized societies. The mere existence of a large number of rules doesn't mean that the regulation is onerous.
- pdonis 13y agoThe mere existence of a large number of rules doesn't mean that the regulation is onerous. So if you're a small business, it's not "onerous" to have to look through myriads of rules to make sure you aren't violating one? To the extent that these regulations are not "onerous", it's because they're ignored, not because they actually work.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoReally? Your argument is from WSJ? That proves that the invisible hand of the market can work this out? I knew libertarianism was sort of naive but surely you jest ... WSJ is hardly known for scientific rigor. I mean this is hard to take seriously. I don't know where to begin. How good would the article be if we were in a time that people may freely be as racist as they want and there were not any social stigmas in the majority about being racist and such racism was commonplace? You would have widespread discrimination and your silly little wouldn't solve anything about it. For those playing at home, this was the status quo in the US at one point. You may argue, as libertarians may, that this is all perfectly fine and is the "moral" way but as usual, with your view of "freedom" we would not have a world many would want to live in.
- pdonis 13y agoYour argument is from WSJ? No, the article that started this thread was from the WSJ, and I was asking a question about it, not endorsing it. Please read before knee-jerk reacting.
- gte910h 13y agoSadly, people don't change their mind until they see it in action. It turns out "Military Integration" => "Less racist military", for instance, rather than the other way around. So yeah, "Force Businesses to Do it by Law" is unfortunately the necessary step