4 ms·
I almost linked to this, too, in the "Western Union says Bitcoin is not ready for international transfer" discussion[1]. The interesting thing about Hawala is
by nl 13y ago
I almost linked to this, too, in the "Western Union says Bitcoin is not ready for international transfer" discussion[1].
The interesting thing about Hawala is that it provides a ready source of liquidity in local currencies. If someone was to link the two (ie, a local Hawala agent accepted a Bitcoin transfer from an untrusted source, and then moved the money via the trusted Hawala network) then almost all the problems of Bitcoin would go away.
It would also set just about every TLA agency in the US looking at you (Semi-anonymous crypto-currency which has been used in drug markets + untracable Islamic money transfer network? There's a techno-thriller plot right there). OTOH, Hawala agents seem to ignore US laws at the moment, so they might not care about this either.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6665635 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6665635
- avi_agrawal 13y agoThat's a very interesting thought, nl. Have a look at Eko (http://eko.co.in http://eko.co.in). Eko is creating a network of trusted agents to service cash-in/ cash-out/ money-transfer needs of billions of non-tech-savvy customers. The cue given by you could be an interesting opportunity for companies like Eko to explore. Kenya's m-Pesa is a similar network of mobile money agents that indeed started accepting Bitcoins recently [2]! [2] http://www.mobilepaymentstoday.com/article/216119/M-PESA-meets-Bitcoin-with-new-service-in-Kenya http://www.mobilepaymentstoday.com/article/216119/M-PESA-mee...
- nl 13y agoThanks, but it hardly takes a genius to point it out (probably should have patented it though..). It's pretty clear that the "bitcoin<->local currency" market is a big one, but dangerous to get into because of regulatory risk. Any players who can avoid that risk somehow have a big advantage. OTOH, if you actually want your mind blown then watch [1]. That's a video of Brad Fitzpatrick pointing out that the Bitcoin protocol allows things like implementing Kickstarter in the Bitcoin protocol itself, or - more relevant to this discussion - things like "Party A pays Party B, but only if Party C vouches for it, and Party C cannot receive the money". [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYukPc0y_Ro#t=970 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sYukPc0y_Ro#t=970
- htmcer 13y agoHawala and other informal networks are accounted for 40% of the remittances sent every year.[1] USD 534 billion were sent in 2012 via formal networks. Analyzing the remittances flow and their impact in the receiving countries (often more in term of %GDP than official intl development aid), it's a shame that the global average fee to "remit" is 9% and up to 12% while sending money towards Sub-Saharan Africa. [2] But that's a fast moving market with several technological and business model innovations (and some YC startups too. This last years, we have seen a lot of startups with interesting ideas based on new technologies or new business model to improve the remittances market: Azimo (http://azimo.com http://azimo.com), Xoom (https://www.xoom.com/ https://www.xoom.com/), Regalii (https://www.regalii.com/ https://www.regalii.com/ - send good instead of cash, YC), Transferwise (http://transferwise.com http://transferwise.com) and new technology like mobile banking (M-Pesa, MTNMMO) and bitcoin (buttercoin YC - http://buttercoin.com/ http://buttercoin.com/). Disclaimer: I work on TawiPay (http://tawipay.com http://tawipay.com) as a side-project, a comparison website for remittances services. [1] http://www.scribd.com/doc/150342765/Trends-in-Remittances-June-2013-The-Anthemis-Newsletter http://www.scribd.com/doc/150342765/Trends-in-Remittances-Ju... [2]https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/sites/default/files/RemittancePriceWorldwide-Analysis-Mar2013.pdf https://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/sites/default/files/R...
- dobbsbob 13y agoAl Jazeera had a good story a while back about migrant workers in South Africa being unable to send money home to Zimbabwe because of huge fees for small amounts, and they have to have ID which costs their whole paycheck
- htmcer 13y agoYeah, South-Africa > Zimbawe is one of the most costly corridor in the world. Starting at 20%...
- miguelrochefort 13y ago> If someone was to link the two (ie, a local Hawala agent accepted a Bitcoin transfer from an untrusted source, and then moved the money via the trusted Hawala network) then almost all the problems of Bitcoin would go away. http://www.ripple.com http://www.ripple.com
- lobo_tuerto 13y agoDoes it work everywhere?
- amalag 13y agoI think the question is, "Is there a ripple gateway for my location/currency"