3 ms·
I'm a fiscal conservative, (actual) small government-type and I'm ok with the related idea of minimum guaranteed income for much the same reason. As you have s
by protomyth 13y ago
I'm a fiscal conservative, (actual) small government-type and I'm ok with the related idea of minimum guaranteed income for much the same reason. As you have said, it seems like there is a huge potential to eliminate quite a number of programs and taxes.
Once you get to the point that transfer payments are not going to go away, it seems like optimizing the cost and efficiency of said payments while reducing the cost (thus taxes) and size of government become priorities. This is basically one way to remove quite a lot of the government.
I'm still not sure about a fixed payment however. I guess I can see a minimum pro-rated[1] guaranteed income payed on a very tight schedule (weekly, but preferably every weekday morning). I can see it would take more paperwork, but I think the difference in payment versus admin costs probably would make it a better pick.
I get the feeling that a country with the constitution that says voting rights are dependent on not taking transfer payments might have a better chance of acceptance. It is a bit of a radical idea.
1) something like for every 2 dollars earned you subtract a dollar of payment
- in2liberty 13y agoThere's a way to do it and actually spend less money on welfare: http://www.morganwarstler.com/post/44789487956/guaranteed-income-choose-your-boss-the-market-based http://www.morganwarstler.com/post/44789487956/guaranteed-in...
- dllthomas 13y ago"Guaranteed Minimum Income" is different than "Basic Income". The latter, which is what is suggested here, involves giving everyone the same amount of money on top of whatever they earn or don't earn. For the former, the government pays the difference between whatever you're actually making and the minimum amount (if positive). With BI there is still incentive to work at low paying jobs - you always keep more as you earn more. With GMI you are basically volunteering until there's a job that pays more than the minimum - it's effectively a different way of implementing a minimum wage.
- protomyth 13y ago"Guaranteed Minimum Income" is different than "Basic Income". Yes, that why I said I was in favor of it (Guaranteed Minimum Income - well actually a pro-rated GMI) for much the same reason sologoub was in favor of the Basic Income from the article. > With BI there is still incentive to work at low paying jobs - you always keep more as you earn more. With GMI you are basically volunteering until there's a job that pays more than the minimum - it's effectively a different way of implementing a minimum wage. That is why I am in favor of a pro-rated version so that there is an incentive to work and people are softly leaving government payments.
- dllthomas 13y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "a pro-rated version of GMI". With basic income, on net people do softly leave government payments as their gross tax payments gradually exceed their (fixed) gross BI.