3 ms·
We don't need a new Constitution. The one we have isn't working only to the extent that the size and scope of the federal government is far larger than it shoul
by ams6110 13y ago
We don't need a new Constitution. The one we have isn't working only to the extent that the size and scope of the federal government is far larger than it should be. We need a new federal government. The Constitution is fine.
- incompatible 13y agoA new federal government would require control by somebody other than Democrats and Republicans, otherwise it's just more of the same. However the US system of elections makes it very difficult to escape from a two party system. As for size and scope of the federal government, that's surely been decided by elected representatives according to the procedures of the constitution?
- gcv 13y agoAn amendment eliminating the Electoral College would go a long way towards fixing the problems outlined in TFA. The Constitution is largely very good, but it unintentionally created a de-facto two party system. With the executive branch free from that sort of nonsense, it may be that the legislature will right itself.
- LammyL 13y agoStates are already half way there at eliminating the electoral college with the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y ago> An amendment eliminating the Electoral College would go a long way towards fixing the problems outlined in TFA. No, it wouldn't. > The Constitution is largely very good, but it unintentionally created a de-facto two party system. With the executive branch free from that sort of nonsense, it may be that the legislature will right itself. Not really; the EC isn't the key feature of the electoral system that produces a two party system, and the features that are -- the fact that most elections, and particularly those for the Congress, are by plurality or majority-runoff methods -- is nowhere in the Constitution, but is the product of statute (and, largely, state statutes.)
- gcv 13y agoFair point. How about an additional amendment spelling out an alternative method for elections to the legislative branch? Do away with plurality and introduce enumerated preferences?
- dragonwriter 13y agoPersonally, I'd prefer no federal Constitutional amendments on the issue, and eliminating the federal statutory barriers to candidate-centered proportional representation, and then letting states try different approaches using preference voting, both in single and multimember districts, before imposing a specific uniform national approach as a Constitutional requirement. First, because its a lot easier to achieve politically, and second, because while I've got pretty clear ideas of both the legislative and executive approaches I think would be best, I don't think its a big enough change that there is plenty of reason to be cautious in imposing a uniform national mandatory rule.
- mjn 13y agoI have the same view as you, except I replace "larger" with "smaller". :)
- gcv 13y agoI know, right? We need more staffing for initiatives like healthcare.gov, and honestly, the security organs aren't doing enough. A larger NSA will, undoubtedly, contribute to a more perfect union.
- mjn 13y agoI think the American mess of healthcare precisely showcases the advantages of a simpler, government-run system. Ever since moving to Denmark, I have not been missing the bureaucratic mess that is the American health-insurance system. Also, much stuff here is built in-house by competent civil servants, not bid out to private-sector contractors like the ones who screwed up healthcare.gov (though that is, alas, somewhat changing). I do think streamlining things would be nice. A large but simple government: everyone gets automatic healthcare coverage by right (like Medicare, but without age limits), everyone gets a basic income rather than some complex web of welfare, etc. Less bureaucracy and maybe even smaller government in terms of pages of regulation/etc., but larger "size" of government in the percent-of-GDP sense. The American approach seems to prefer complex but low-benefit government, with huge piles of eligibility rules and private-sector provision, instead of just simple blanket benefits.