5 ms·
Australia has profited enormously from the US Constitution. Our own Constitution was drafted in the wake of the American Civil War and with observations gleane
by jacques_chester 13y ago
Australia has profited enormously from the US Constitution.
Our own Constitution was drafted in the wake of the American Civil War and with observations gleaned from decades of US politics. Take for example section 55 of our Constitution: it requires a tax Act to only deal with taxation, and only with one tax subject. This makes rider clauses flatly impossible.
Similarly, when we held a referendum to become a republic, the model proposed deliberately avoided introducing an elected President as it was seen as introducing a new and destabilising power base that would eventually lead to a constitutional crisis.
Still. I don't think that the tide of crisis in the US has risen sufficiently high to trigger a mood for amendment, especially given the quasi-religious lionisation of the drafters of the US Constitution. They were intelligent men solving a problem, not prophets. Frankly I think a lot of them would be calling for amendments in order to solve the unforeseen dynamics that have subsequently emerged.
Settle in, there's going to more of the same in decades to come. There is a lot of ruin in a nation, as Smith observed, and the USA is the wealthiest and most powerful nation in history.
- firstOrder 13y ago> avoided introducing an elected President as it was seen as introducing a new and destabilising power base that would eventually lead to a constitutional crisis. Sure you just have a representative of the Monarch who boots elected prime ministers when she becomes displeased with them, like axing the, of course, Labor PM in 1975. When Charles I disbanded parliament, ultimately he found his own head chopped off. Australia's Liberals are lucky the modern Labor party is so milquetoast.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThe Queen has no direct input into Australian affairs and the dismissal of Whitlam, which was found to be Constitutional, led immediately to new elections. Nothing had to be shut down and the whole matter was settled peacefully within a few weeks. In the USA certain constitutional crises betwixt Presidents and Congress have led to civil war. I'm just going to say that Australia is still in front on this one.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> In the USA certain constitutional crises betwixt Presidents and Congress have led to civil war The US has only had one civil war, and it wasn't a result of a Constitutional crisis between the President and the Congress.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI'm sorry, you're right, it was a constitutional crisis born of a policy dispute.
- npsimons 13y agoAustralia has profited enormously from the US Constitution. Our own Constitution was drafted in the wake of the American Civil War and with observations gleaned from decades of US politics. If you read the Federalist Papers, it's interesting to note how much of history (going back to the ancients, ie Sparta, Athens, etc) the writers of the US constitution studied. That's not to say that they were perfect (I try not to hero worship myself; it often leads either to disappointment or distortions), but it's also nice to see the whole "learn from history" aphorism put into practice.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe Federalist Papers were written after the Constitution -- they were political ads for the campaign for ratification.
- npsimons 13y agoOops, my bad; corrected. EDIT: While I will agree that the Federalist Papers were strong rhetoric, and I can think of examples that contradict many of the axioms of them, I also believe it is very enlightening to read them because they reveal how much the framers of the US constitution had studied of other governments.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThey were also familiar with the concepts and theories that had not long before been published in France by Montesquieu, Rousseau, Diderot and others. Jacques Barzun argues that "Revolution" is the wrong term for what happened in the USA, even as a convenient shorthand. There was no widespread transfer of property and no wholesale breakdown of social order. It was a struggle of a local elite against a remote elite. He exclusively uses "War of Independence" in his historical writing.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Jacques Barzun argues that "Revolution" is the wrong term for what happened in the USA, even as a convenient shorthand. There was no widespread transfer of property and no wholesale breakdown of social order. While they sometimes coincide, political, social, and economic revolutions are really separate things; the absence of the elements identified doesn't really say anything about whether or not it was a political revolution.