3 ms·
What benefit does solemnization provide beyond its ability to facilitate authentication?
by SilasX 13y ago
What benefit does solemnization provide beyond its ability to facilitate authentication?
- GhotiFish 13y ago"but your honour, I just slipped when I pressed the button, I tried to sort it out but the owner was not listening to reason!" vs "but your honour, I just slipped and made a replica of my signature. Stop looking at me like that." it does establish clear intent. IANAL though.
- lisper 13y ago> I just slipped when I pressed the button No. The screw case is when someone says: I pressed the button, but the document I was agreeing to was not the document that the plaintiff is presenting, it is this completely different document over here.
- s_kilk 13y agoCorrect, in the digital realm there is absolutely nothing that actually binds the .png of your signature to the document which you were supposedly "signing". That's a huge problem.
- patio11 13y agoThere are about four elements to a contractual relationship: offer, acceptance, consideration, and the intent to establish a legal relationship. You need to have all four. Many people will, in loose conversation, throw out three of them (+), in such a way as to give their counterparty the impression that a contract exists. This is not always done in a malicious fashion -- in the rough and tumble of business negotiations sometimes one party thinks they're discussing options and another thinks they're discussing plans. Signing physical contracts -- which is often not actually required in contract law (though it can be for certain transactions in certain jurisdictions) -- gives both parties an unambiguous, socially-ironclad touchstone that says We Are Engaged In Serious Business. If you're willing to sign something, you're willing to be bound, if not, you aren't. + "I was wondering if you gave any thought to the consulting proposal, for 2 weeks at $20k a week?" "We want to do it." has offer and consideration but the acceptance and intent to create a contract are ambiguous. It's entirely possible for one side of the negotiation to think "Sweet, it's on" and the other side to think "For God's sake, that was a pleasantry!" Some people feel that certain online relationships would be improved by physical or physical-like contract signing, for the solemnization aspect. I've wrestled with this myself. For example, medical providers can't use Appointment Reminder without agreeing to a Business Associates Agreement. The BAA is not your bog-standard clickwrap ToS -- in event of a breach or HIPAA violation it could be at the center of a $X00,000 enforcement action. I currently force people to actually print and sign contracts rather than doing the clicky-clicky thing just to convey to them Yes This Is Official.
- dctoedt 13y ago> There are about four elements to a contractual relationship: offer, acceptance, consideration, and the intent to establish a legal relationship. You need to have all four. This is close, but the part about intent is not quite the way courts approach such questions under Anglo-American contract law. The issue of intent is subsumed in the issues of offer and acceptance. Importantly, intent is addressed from an objective perspective; the parties' subjective intentions generally don't matter. Generally speaking, if a person takes an action that, viewed objectively, looks like an offer or an acceptance, then the person's subjective intention is not relevant. [1] An edge case is where one or both parties expressly state that they don't intend to be legally bound (for example, in a letter of intent). [2] That would normally be analyzed as, there was no offer, and/or no acceptance, because a reasonable person would not regard the parties as having assented to being bound. Which brings us to: > "We want to do it." has offer and consideration but the acceptance and intent to create a contract are ambiguous. It's entirely possible for one side of the negotiation to think "Sweet, it's on" and the other side to think "For God's sake, that was a pleasantry!" The issue here would be simply whether, viewed objectively, there was an acceptance. My guess is that most lawyers and judges would say no -- that We want to do it was not an acceptance, but was a non-binding "invitation to treat" [3]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Offer_and_acceptance#Offer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Offer_and_acceptance#Offer [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract#Intention_to_be_legally_bound http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contract#Intention_to_be_legall... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Offer_and_acceptance#Invitations_to_treat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Offer_and_acceptance#Invitation...
- SilasX 13y agoSo what benefit does solemnization provide beyond its facilitating authentication of the agreement to the contract? How could you provide authentication in a way that doesn't confirm you are in serious business?
- mikeash 13y agoIt shows you weren't just screwing around, basically. It removes the defense of "I didn't agree to that." (Versus "I didn't agree to that.") Without that, the other party can do whatever they feel like to prove that the person they dealt with was you, but without something that actually indicates you agreed to be bound by the contract (typically a signature), it doesn't matter if they have your birth certificate and driver's license and DNA sample, you're not bound to anything.