2 ms·
Site-wide bans really rub me the wrong way. It implies a very simpleminded, idealistic understanding of organizations, as if all the writers and editors were a
by danso 13y ago
Site-wide bans really rub me the wrong way. It implies a very simpleminded, idealistic understanding of organizations, as if all the writers and editors were a single hivemind -- as one spams, so do all the others. But the reality is more complicated than that, and while there are pragmatic considerations at play here, it's sad that there can't be a more granular-kind of ban, because each of these organizations put out some fine works of journalism, no matter what your gut reaction to the organization may be.
Huffington Post, for example, won a Pulitzer last year for an extremely important (and still undercovered) topic:
http://www.pulitzer.org/citation/2012-National-Reporting http://www.pulitzer.org/citation/2012-National-Reporting
As far as HN goes, I wish HN could remove the site-level ban on Buzzfeed. Yes, mercilessly flag the shit out of its "23 Gifs about some Linkbait topic" articles, but they've been investing some money and resources into serious and original work.
They have a longform section:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/longform http://www.buzzfeed.com/longform
They were the employer of Michael Hastings, the late-investigative reporter who died in a LA car wreck: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/michael-hastings-rolling-stone-contributor-dead-at-33-20130618 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/michael-hastings-r...
And they recently hired one of my former colleagues, Pulitzer Prize winner Mark Schoofs, from ProPublica, to lead a new investigative team:
http://jimromenesko.com/2013/10/21/mark-schoofs-leaves-propublica-to-head-buzzfeeds-investigative-unit/ http://jimromenesko.com/2013/10/21/mark-schoofs-leaves-propu...
Then again, you could always argue that BuzzFeed's (and their linkbaity peers) good contributions aren't yet enough to outweigh the burden of modding their junk.