4 ms·
At the height of the moon mission, we spent 4.4% of our GDP trying to get to the moon. We did it, and haven't been back in 40 years. What you're saying does n
by melling 13y ago
At the height of the moon mission, we spent 4.4% of our GDP trying to get to the moon. We did it, and haven't been back in 40 years. What you're saying does not work.
- ck2 13y agoHow can you measure the return on investment for all we learned from trying to get to the moon? From inspiring so many people to go into science. I don't think building better war machines inspires people to go into science.
- potatolicious 13y agoYou can't measure the ROI, and honestly the ROI argument is as rhetorical and handwavy as the "TSA makes us safer" argument. It only feels somewhat plausible, but is so utterly vague and unmeasurable that there's simply no way to make it not an empty statement. Also, I'm as anti-warmongering as everyone else here, but it's a patently false claim to say that the industry of war doesn't drive massive leaps in science and technology. Silicon Valley itself was birthed out of massive military research funding post-WW2. The Internet started as a DARPA project. The foundational technology we built on top of to get the moon was reversed engineered in large part out of deadly German V2 rockets captured during the war. Hell, one of the biggest chief architects of the US space program was Wernher von Braun, whose rocketry expertise came out of Nazi Germany. The Russians weren't exempt either - all of their early satellite and manned mission launch vehicles were derivatives of ICBMs - Sputnik, the first satellite in orbit, launched from a R-7 ICBM. I wish it weren't the case, but there is tons of evidence, all around the world and all throughout history, that the waging of war drives a shitload of science.
- melling 13y agoI think you missed my point. We weren't inspired enough to continue once we reached the moon. We did not continue on to Mars, and we didn't want to increase NASA's budget. Most people here weren't even born when we went to the moon. Consider that we need to import engineers in the US because many Americans don't want to do the job.
- mikeash 13y agoWhy, because they quit spending it? The US spends 4-5% of its GDP on defense every year, year after year, without end. When you fund gigantic science projects and then kill the funding as soon as they show any success, well, surprise! They stop. So don't do that. Maybe we could drop defense spending to a mere 3% of GDP (still more, in absolute terms, than any other country in the world, and a level seen as recently as 2001) and spend the leftovers on space and other science research.