5 ms·
Is there a standard answer when someone complains about the "war machine" and incorrect priorities? It's kind of common in this crowd, and probably not the pro
by melling 13y ago
Is there a standard answer when someone complains about the "war machine" and incorrect priorities? It's kind of common in this crowd, and probably not the proper way to look at it. To me, it's a Frequently Mentioned Complaint.
Certainly many of us here wish there was more money spent on big science. For example, if the US built Super Collider 20 years ago, what we are discovering in physics today, would have been discovered almost 2 decades ago:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_Super_Collider http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_Super_Collider
Anyway, the US spends a fortune on its military. The cost was something like 20 billion for air conditioning in the Iraq war? (that's one supercollider). Until we have that ever elusive world peace, we're probably going to continue to spend a fortune. Having the military spend some of its money on new SR71's, robotic vehicles, the Internet, drones, etc isn't going to be cheapest research but fewer people question it, and the research does get done.
Consider that if we didn't need national defense, people would probably just want lower taxes and you still couldn't convince them to go to the moon. There's nothing there, after all.
- drzaiusapelord 13y ago>Until we have that ever elusive world peace, we're probably going to continue to spend a fortune. We spend 10x what China does. We don't have to spend as much. >people would probably just want lower taxes Heaven forbid I have more cash in my wallet. More for me to invest to help fund companies that do interesting things, perhaps even go to the moon with. I personally don't mind my tax load if it gave us things like universal healthcare and cheaper higher education and better infrastructure. I do mind it when it just powers the various killing machines at our disposal and wars based on clear lies like "yellowcake" and "WMDs." How many Mars missions did Iraq cost us? >and the research does get done. Locked away as classified or patent encumbered via Lockheed or whoever is developing $expensive_weapons_system? Yeah, we can do better. edit: The list linked on spending doesn't include all the special spending bills that paid for the Iraq and Afghani wars. Yes, we are close to spending 10x what Russia spends and probably closer to 5 or 6x what China spends. I mixed up my countries, but we are GREATLY overspending. NASA's annual budget is about a month in Afghanistan. We've spend at LEAST 2 trillion in Iraq and Afghanistan. 4 is you count actual expenditures and future commitments like medical and disability. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/14/iraq-war-cost-more-than-2-trillion_n_2875493.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/14/iraq-war-cost-more-...
- melling 13y agoYou are incorrect on what China spends. They are closing the gap, and I imagine their equipment actually costs them less per unit. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_e...
- greedo 13y agoHowever, we don't have to worry just about China. We have to worry about Iran, NK, China, Russia, etc. So just looking at what China spends isn't that useful.
- mcv 13y agoBecause Iran and North Korea are a threat to the US in what fantasy world exactly? China and Russia matter. Iran and North Korea are just diversions.
- greedo 13y agoMilitary planning doesn't really think in terms of threats as much as capabilities. Despite the last 60 years, friends often turn into competitors/enemies when you least expect it.
- mcv 13y agoI wasn't suggesting Iran and North Korea were friends. I was suggesting they lack capabilities.
- greedo 13y agoIf you think NK lacks the capabilities to affect the US, you're misguided. Or you don't care about US troops stationed in South Korea, Okinawa, etc. Same with Iran. It doesn't take much to cause trouble. Ask the dead Marines killed by Iranian backed terror groups in Lebanon in the 1980's.
- 13y ago
- Zigurd 13y ago> Until we have that ever elusive world peace, we're probably going to continue to spend a fortune. Perhaps it can be a smaller fortune, like half, or a third. Nobody on the planet except the US can cross an ocean to fight a war. Nobody is withing decades, maybe more than a century of being able to do that. Every weapon the US has will be a museum piece by then. With the end of the Soviet Union, the "come as you are" war is also obsolete. Any emerging threat will emerge slowly enough that a military build-up can take years, if needed.
- bluedino 13y ago>> Consider that if we didn't need national defense, people would probably just want lower taxes and you still couldn't convince them to go to the moon. We have 1.5 million active military personnel and almost 1 million in reserves. Then you've got at least another million employed by contractors like Lockheed Martin, Northrop Grunman, etc. You'd devastate the economy by getting rid of the military. It's a huge jobs program.
- kcorbitt 13y agoIn the short term you're right. But if the cuts were done responsibly over time the economy would adapt and the capital we currently spend on the military would be reallocated to more productive areas. Claiming that we can never cut military spending because it would hurt the economy is an example of the broken window fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- ISL 13y agoBringing up the SSC should be done carefully. It's true that Congress killed the project after a lot of money had been spent, land acquired, facilities built, and people relocated. On the flip side, the management of the project was far from perfect, and it was expected to go far over budget. If you want to further particle physics these days, campaign for funding the ILC [1]. The Japanese are very interested in hosting and supporting the effort. While the energy is smaller (500 GeV - 1 TeV), the energy per particle (protons are made of three quarks; most collisions at LHC are between gluons) is comparable or greater. Lepton-antilepton colliders are what you really want to do precision science; protons are only used because they're energetically advantageous. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Linear_Collider http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Linear_Collider
- lostlogin 13y agoEver elusive peace... America has had a big role in many post WW2 conflicts and not in a good way. Perhaps recognizing that America isn't necessarily the good guy would lead to less voter acceptance of the military budget.