8 ms·
Only 6 people managed to enroll in an insurance plan on Day 1 of Healthcare.gov
- felipesabino 13y agoI bet the data is still being processed by some of those 500 million lines of code
- Bsharp 13y ago> "The first month of the new health law’s rollout reveals an unexpected pattern in several states: a crush of people applying for an expansion of Medicaid and a trickle of sign-ups for private insurance. This early imbalance — in some places nine out of 10 enrollees are in Medicaid — has taken some experts by surprise. The Affordable Care Act, which expanded Medicaid to cover millions of the poorest Americans who couldn’t otherwise afford coverage, envisions a more even split with an expanded, robust private market..." So you're telling me that more people who are getting free benefits showed up to the party than people who have to pay significant annual premiums? Shocking. I think they need new "experts".
- refurb 13y agoI think what they are referring to is the impact of the individual mandate. Sure you'd expect people to rush into the free option, but everyone who is uninsured and doesn't qualify for Medicaid will have have to pay a penalty if they don't buy insurance.
- mikeash 13y agoSure, but what's the hurry? If you don't really want to buy insurance but are doing it to avoid the penalty, you might as well wait until the deadline is closer.
- McDermot 13y agoDefinitely. However the concern here is that people ignore the individual mandate's penalty. Precisely nobody wants that, and the hope was that the ease of signing up and looking for insurance via exchanges would provide a carrot or at least a smooth road to go along with the stick of the penalty. Whoopfail.
- mikeash 13y agoThe carrot isn't really in play either, yet, since there's no advantage to signing up before December. Coverage starts at the same date either way, so why bother now?
- powertower 13y agoPay 1.0-2.5% tax penalty for not having Insurance Pay 10-15% of your pre-tax income for a plan under Obamacare I don't think it's going to work out that great.
- Bsharp 13y agoIt depends on your expected medical costs. If you're relatively young and healthy, saving that 9-12.5% of your income is worth it. If you're sick/old/etc., then it's absolutely worth buying coverage. Note that in this system the healthy don't join the risk pool. This, my friend, is called adverse selection.
- fr0sty 13y agoThe goalposts have already been moved to March 31st, 2014 and could be delayed further. What's the rush?
- hga 13y agoAdverse selection death spiral (https://www.google.com/search?q=obamacare+Adverse+selection+death+spiral https://www.google.com/search?q=obamacare+Adverse+selection+...), and moving the goalposts too far forward means insurance companies, which have to submit 2015 plans in the January through March (as I recall; maybe April) period will have very poor data to do that with, very possibly resulting in higher than needed costs. And while I don't think you were addressing this, millions will lose their now outlawed plans on January 1.
- GVIrish 13y agoAnd while I don't think you were addressing this, millions will lose their now outlawed plans on January 1. I see this as a huge impending disaster that could turn public sentiment against ACA to the point that it does get repealed. If people get their old plans cancelled and it is very difficult to use healthcare.gov to sign up for a new plan, a lot of people are going to be left in the lurch. Unfortunately the horse is already out of the barn and into the next county. Maybe by a stroke of luck healthcare.gov will be functioning smoothly at the end of November like Obama and company have said it would. But I'd be willing to bet this will not be the case, given all the problems that project has to deal with. Even if a massive effort were put underway to stand up call centers so people could navigate the healthcare exchanges over the phone, it would still need to be administered via a computer system, there's little chance a wide-scale paper process could be put in place quickly at this point.
- hga 13y agoShock and awe, anyone? On the one hand it's around 5% of the population, and unless you need subsidies, you can get policies directly from the insurers, and there are private comparison shopping sites. On the other hand, most will have to pay more money, often a LOT more, often for worse coverage in ways they most care about, and this small fraction of the population includes some of the most influential. Maybe ... the rules of that seem to be changing, this could in fact be a good test of the recent Angelo Codevilla et. al. modern US ruling and country classes thesis.
- Bsharp 13y agoOf course people will enroll eventually, but the first ones will be the ones with the most to gain. It isn't guaranteed that individuals won't eat the penalty and enroll when they need it, but you can guarantee that people who benefit with little or no cost to them will be want their benefits ASAP. My point was mostly that if their "experts" can't think critically about the incentive system the program creates, what else will they be surprised about? Adverse selection? Insurer bankruptcy and industry consolidation?
- jdmonty 13y agoSo, SNL had it right when they said the site could only handle 6 users at a time http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2013/10/27/saturday_night_live_mocks_sebelius_for_disastrous_obamacare_website_launch.html http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2013/10/27/saturday_n...
- jdmonty 13y agoSo, SNL had it right when they said the site could only handle 6 users at a time http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2013/10/27/saturday_night_live_mocks_sebelius_for_disastrous_obamacare_website_launch.html http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2013/10/27/saturday_n...
- ceejayoz 13y agoFor reference, only 123 managed to sign up for Romneycare in the first month. There are clearly large technical issues, but early on it seems that people also do a lot of "let's see how much it'd cost" and sign up later.
- josefresco 13y agoLink? Would love to read up on that, if in fact it's true.
- jonlucc 13y agoI agree that data is preferred, but we can also look at it another way. There is no incentive to sign up before December 15th. All plans signed up before then start Jan 1. With all of the talk about the technical limitations, I think people are right to wait a month until people aren't ranting about it being broken.
- pbz 13y agohttp://www.businessinsider.com/obama-obamacare-romneycare-boston-speech-2013-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/obama-obamacare-romneycare-bo...
- joshuahedlund 13y agoHere's a source[1] for the sibling commenter. But there's a key difference - AFAIK Romneycare didn't start having to dig itself out of a hole of millions of people losing coverage as well. [1]http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/10/29/romneycare-had-super-slow-enrollment-the-white-house-says-obamacare-will-be-similar/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/10/29/r...
- newsreader 13y agoNot a good comparison. Romneycare was implemented in one state, Obamacare is nation wide.
- hga 13y ago
- uptown 13y agoCompletely separate issue from the technical issues - but how are people expected to find out that they need to do this. I have to assume there's a non-trivial percentage of the population that's not only uninsured but also completely disconnected from news and the internet. Does somebody contact them somehow to get them enrolled?
- Bsharp 13y agoLike taxes, this will likely be a largely individual endeavor. Maybe there will be PSAs, but their effectiveness is questionable. Many people (and the politicians who signed it!) don't know the enrollment requirements, subsequent responsibilities, and consequences for failure to comply. Everyone is fighting over the validity and constitutionality of this law, instead of informing the public about what they need to do to avoid financial penalties. The debate will rage on no matter what, but whether or not you agree with this law (and I don't), the priority right now should be to help people make an informed decision about their compliance.
- drivingmissm 13y agoI think civil disobedience is appropriate, and that people should resist compliance and urge others to resist. I believe that the individual mandate is unconstitutional and that the law was passed in a party-line vote using shady Senate tactics. Further, we now know that President Obama flat-out knowingly lied when he told the public "if you like your plan you can keep it." The law needs to be delayed so that Congress can pass a bipartisan health care reform bill. This issue is too important to not have achieved a governing consensus.
- mikeash 13y agoThis is as bi-partisan as you can get. The Democrats passed the Republicans' plan. The only reason it didn't get any Republican support was because the Republicans are completely nuts. There is no way to get their support for anything right now.
- 13y ago
- pmorici 13y agoPerhaps because of the sticker shock and because, if you can get them, pre ACA plans are cheaper and offer more value. For example if you go to ehealthinsurance.com and compare the lowest cost pre-ACA 2013 plans with ACA-compliant 2014 plans for a healthy individual in their late 20's early thirties you get the following very affordable options pre-ACA... BlueCross BlueShield; Deductible: $5,000, Co-Insurance: 0%, Doctor Visit: 1-2 $30 co-pay deductible waved, Cost: $98 /month BlueCross BlueShield; Deductible: $5,000, Co-Insurance: 0%, Doctor Visit: 1-2 $30 co-pay deductible waved, Cost: $66 /month, The closest ACA compliant option to the above... BlueCross BlueShield; Deductible: $6,000, Co-Insurance: 0%, Doctor Visit: no charge after deductible, Cost: $130 /month So in summary you are looking at paying somewhere between 32% and 97% more money, and don't get the benefit of 1-2 low cost doctors visits per year.
- tptacek 13y agoAren't you comparing conditionally-issued insurance with guaranteed-issue health insurance? The big problem I had with sites like ehealthinsurance.com is that a family using it to find insurance had a coinflip chance of actually getting one of those rates after completing an application.
- atwebb 13y agoI've also found it's like viewing interest rates on Zillow, it will be the lowest possible number that almost no one could qualify for but, it looks nice when shopping and gets people thinking they can afford it so the small increases later are accepted.
- pmorici 13y agoYes, but how many people is that actually an issue for? Most of the preexisting condition demagoguery you hear about seems to stem from people who were going w/o insurance until they found out they had a medical condition. There were already limits on preexisting condition exclusions in a number of states. You also have to wonder if that in and of itself is worth a doubling in costs? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-existing_condition#Current_pre-existing_condition_exclusion_regulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-existing_condition#Current_...
- ck2 13y agoLook I am the first to be upset at how much healthcare.gov management and dev sucked. But I don't give a darn how many signed up on the first day. I care how many sign up by December 31st. Then we can discuss enrollment problems.
- abarringer 13y agoNo, the date is Dec. 15th. If your one of the apparently millions whose plan didn't meet the new guidelines then you must sign up by Dec. 15th.