5 ms·
but say I want a smartphone, what is my alternative? google, who works harder and harder to sell everything I do to advertisers (now you can't even rate apps w
by x0x0 13y ago
but say I want a smartphone, what is my alternative?
google, who works harder and harder to sell everything I do to advertisers (now you can't even rate apps w/o a google+ account), and who just shut off transmitting search data so they can screw site owners for more $?
microsoft, who is a party to this and actively worked to make the internet worse (and succeeded!) for the better part of a decade?
or apple, who at least isn't run by and for advertisers?
all choices suck
- WaterSponge 13y agoMarketing is a natural occurrence. All companies/people/groups market themselves in one way or another. Your not exactly forced to buy into whats being sold. Why is everyone so stuck on google core being a marketing company? I think its the least of evil profit motivations since hell I might actually be interested in what google has figured out I may want... Vs being locked out without any options and force into dealing with a certain player.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoFor me the issue isn't marketing itself. It's that in order to show me personalized ads they need to know a lot about me. They have to compile and store a personal profile that can be stolen or subpoenaed by anyone who is sufficiently capable or powerful. But I agree that there is a dilemma. The alternative to ad based business models is to make a payment via a credit card, which identifies me even more directly and is subject to even tighter regulation and potential censorship. In the extreme, I have to deal with companies like Apple enforcing their broken moral standards on my phone. There are no simple solutions to this I'm afraid.
- gaius 13y agoMicrosoft and Apple make money by selling actual products. Google makes money by selling you.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoGoogle isn't selling me. They're selling a service based on information they get from me in exchange for a product they make for me. It's just another form of payment. Every form of payment comes with it's own benefits and drawbacks. (I didn't downvote you by the way. I never downvote)
- gaius 13y agoExcept it's not as simple as "don't use GMail and you're safe" - they have their finger in every pie via their ad system. You can very, very easily opt-out of using MS or Apple products.
- fpgeek 13y agoDo you really think Microsoft and Apple don't sell "you" too? They have (admittedly less-successful) advertising businesses that they show no signs of abandoning, they boast about the number of accounts and/or the number of credit cards they have for developers and partners and so on. To a first approximation "everybody" wants your money and "everybody" sells you. Generalizations don't work. You need to look at the bundles that come with products/ecosystems on a case-by-case basis.
- vdaniuk 13y agoI am quite happy to be served personalized ads from Google and even Facebook. I regularly get ads for services that interest me greatly, like digitalocean, heroku, cloud66, newrelic, edx, codeschool, teamtreehouse. Thanks, personalized ads!
- rednukleus 13y agoBuy an Android, and if you are worried about Google's targeted ads, then don't link it to a Google account. Or put Ubuntu or FirefoxOS on there. There may not be a perfect option out there with no tradeoffs, but there are options that are far far worse for the industry than others.
- zurn 13y agoFirefox OS and Jolla. Firefox OS + ZTE Open: cheap and good battery life (70€ / $80, 2-7 days).
- bad_user 13y agoRight now Firefox OS on ZTE Open is a work in progress. It has tremendous potential, but in case you get one, don't expect the level of polish you get with the popular alternatives. But it's improving and it will get there and if you can, buying one is a good way to support its development.
- dreen 13y agoI would buy Jolla right away if it had a hw keyboard. There may be a FOS device worth buying but I havent seen one yet. I am way overdue for a replacement, and sadly, I need to agree with your parent - there is nothing interesting on the market at the moment.
- bad_user 13y agoPeople bitch and moan about Gmail serving ads and yet people bitched and moaned when Google Apps dropped the free version, even though with paid accounts you don't get ads anymore and the pricing of Google Apps is insanely good compared to the alternatives. Android, Chrome, Chrome OS are open-source. Amazon already forked Android. Android is also the only popular mobile operating-system that allows installation of software from third-party sources. And if you use Android, you don't have to buy into Google's services. In my eyes it doesn't matter that Apple isn't being "run for" advertisers. Because Apple sure as hell isn't operating their business in my interests either.
- bzbarsky 13y agoChrome is not in fact open-source. Chromium is open-source, but lacks various functionality Chrome has (e.g. the PDF reader, and soon I expect playback of Netflix videos, since I doubt Google will be open-sourcing their CDM). Chromium is also supporting Flash via NPAPI, not Pepper, which Google is planning to kill off. ChromeOS has similar issues with Netflix, at the very least: the open-source parts can't do it.
- bad_user 13y agoWell, that's true. But then when companies like Mozilla try to fight proprietary stuff like H.264 or DRM (because duh, these are incompatible with open-source), people start bitching about it. And that's why we can't have nice things, because some people suck. You forgot about the Google Talk plugin, which was something that was upsetting me personally, but hopefully they'll fulfil their promise of moving to Web RTC. Note - I'm actually a Firefox user, because when Mozilla wants to improve the state of PDF rendering, they do it in such a way that everybody benefits, i.e. https://github.com/mozilla/pdf.js https://github.com/mozilla/pdf.js
- Joeri 13y agoMicrosoft earns $10 per android handset, they make more from android than windows phone. So regardless of whether you buy windows phone or android you're paying microsoft. Apple and microsoft have a long-standing patent sharing arrangement, so they don't pay each other money. So, you can pay apple or pay microsoft to get access to a smartphone. Given the amount of patents they hold, any smartphone os is either flying under their radar or in their sights. If firefox or ubuntu succeed with their phone OS, they will get sued. The problem is not these companies, it's the regulatory climate. Until we defang technology patents it will remain like this, with only a few tollkeepers who own the market.
- honzzz 13y agoThe problem is not these companies, it's the regulatory climate. But why is the regulatory climate so problematic? I guess it's because our current form of democracy is highly inefficient - politicians have much stronger incentives to do what rich entities represented by lobbying firms want than they have incentives to do what is beneficial for the general public. Bad laws are basically written by those who benefit from them and that's why it takes so long to change the bad laws and that's why the new laws are always half-assed and full of loopholes. This is not going to change any time soon. The more I think about it the more I think that government regulation is neither fair nor efficient and I wonder... how difficult would it be to partially escape government regulation by creating a distributed company? Think of Linux on Bitcoins. No single entity to sue. Some kind of self-regulation based on millions of stakeholders carefully disconnected from their real-world identities voting with their money or something. This is just a very vague idea - I am not sure it could solve anything and I am pretty sure that it would create a lot of new problems but I feel it is useful to think about this stuff because we cannot expect governments to efficiently regulate society in a way beneficial to general public. Democracy needs to improve in order to keep up.
- corresation 13y agoMicrosoft earns $10 per android handset No they don't. This is one of those factoids that gains truth through repeated assertion, but it simply isn't true.
- grey-area 13y agobut say I want a smartphone, what is my alternative? I agree all mainstream choices suck, but there are alternatives: FirefoxOS or Ubuntu Phone
- stusmith1977 13y agoSurely open-source handset OSes are just as vulnerable to patent attacks? If Firefox OS were to take off, it would immediately become a target for exactly the same sort of lawsuit.
- grey-area 13y agoThe question was not how do I buy a smartphone which is invulnerable to patent attacks/lawsuits, but how can I avoid supporting this kind of predatory corporate behaviour (Apple, Google, MS were listed as examples). I agree open source handsets (as far as they can be) would also be vulnerable to software patent attacks, but we could at least support companies which don't engage in such attacks.
- chris_wot 13y agoHow did Microsoft make the Internet worse?
- m_mueller 13y agoFor example by not supporting standards like svg and png as long as they had the market leadership?
- kvb 13y agoOn the other hand they ensured that every Windows user had free access to a high quality browser (at least, at the time IE6 came out).
- m_mueller 13y agoWell yes, I think with 'decade' GP was referring to everything from the advent of firefox to the introduction of IE9, which might not actually amount to a decade (didn't check). Within this timeframe MS was severely lagging behind in standards, thus requiring everyone to choose between * support only IE (which they were hoping for of course) * introduce browser conditionals everywhere * only use a very limited feature set as the lowest common denominator (leading to table layouts everywhere, using jpg instead of png, never even think about transparency) This did IMO slow down the development of the web as a whole for quite some time.
- code_duck 13y agoBy strongly pushing a browser that was rarely updated meaningfully and featured very slow JavaScript and buggy, incomplete CSS support. This held back the viability of web apps for years after they would have otherwise been viable.
- asadotzler 13y agoMozilla is working on your alternative with Firefox OS. We're still very early but there is no doubt in my mind that Firefox OS is going to do to the smartphone market what Firefox did for the browser market, get vendors fighting over users and developers by improving the user and developer experiences and opportunities. We need a real competitor here with a completely different kind of agenda and, IMO, Mozilla is the competitor to do that. (Yes, I work for Mozilla on Firefox OS, but I'm not just spouting off. It took us a while to get from Mozilla in 1998 to Firefox but we did it and it fixed the browser market. We're getting into phones for the same reason and you can help us fix this market by joining the Mozilla Firefox OS project.)