4 ms·
I'm constantly amazed that its like everyone has suddenly forgotten that during Occupy Wall St, protests before and since, and the entire Arab Spring revolution
by XorNot 13y ago
I'm constantly amazed that its like everyone has suddenly forgotten that during Occupy Wall St, protests before and since, and the entire Arab Spring revolution, it was portable and mobile recording devices widely dispersed amongst the populace that enabled successful revolution against government and evidence and checks of the abuses of power of police and other authorities.
- penguindev 13y agoOWS was successful at something? What would that be...
- steveklabnik 13y agoThere are a number of things OWS was successful at: 1. re-igniting a national conversation about the nature of wealth and who has it and for what reasons. 2. Giving a large number of people who were isolated in their individual homes a space to come build some kind of community. 3. Several sub-organizations, such as Occupy Sandy and Strike Debt, have been incredibly successful in their niche. 4. A whole new generation of people were introduced into some aspect of activist culture. Those are just some, off the top of my head.
- penguindev 13y agoThat sounds like a bureaucrats definition of success. "It's not about accomplishing real work, it's about the process, getting involved in the process, etc. etc." Seeing how wall st. is at all time highs using printed money, and the largest mega banks are still mega, it's a bit optimistic to call OWS a success. Don't get me wrong, I think it was a great effort... and I really like the 1%/99% coining... but perhaps it's time to look at reality.
- steveklabnik 13y agoYou are assuming that "destroy the banks" is the win condition. I'm saying that's not correct. It's a long game.
- notahacker 13y agoTo an extent, yes. Whether open communication aids or harms you depends on whose misdemeanours you're communicating, and to whom. Two years on from Arab Spring, there are grainy new videos posted of abuses of power in Egypt every day. Whereas on the 27th January 2011, Mubarak's government was so disconcerted by the volume of criticism it was getting it actually largely succeeded in switching the internet off...
- XorNot 13y agoWhich is kind of my point. Unless you're distributing devices which the users can't get their own images out of, but someone else can, then your fundamentally decentralizing the power structure. The government is bigger then you, it has more resources then you and its been able to monopolize surveillance more effectively then you. But the pushback against that is not what I would argue we'd expect - you don't try and eliminate surveillance, you democratize it.