3 ms·
That's absolutely right. So you want to deter everyone according to the severity of the "crime", right? Why do you want to deter poor people more than rich peop
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
That's absolutely right. So you want to deter everyone according to the severity of the "crime", right? Why do you want to deter poor people more than rich people? The damage is the same. If you punish one person with life long poverty and the other with a small reduction of pocket money, you won't achieve what you want. I don't want wealthy people speeding just because they can afford it as their speeding is just as dangerous as everyone elses.
It comes down to the concept of cost that you are using. What is cost? Dollars? I don't think so. It's how much of your living time you have to spend in order to pay for something. That's what fines should be related to.
- Erwin 17y agoFinland, Norway issue speeding tickets based on a percentage of income, see e.g. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/3477285.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/3477285.stm where a €170,000 was issued in 2004. I don't know of any studies of the effects of that. But there's certainly a nice Schadenfreude effect when you invariably read about slightly rich guy in Finland getting a giant fine in just about every news publication in the world. (If they made that the law in e.g. US I wonder if some sheriff's department would get the idea to have policemen exclusively to follow around wealthy drivers -- in the style of drug property seizures and overtuned red-light cameras)
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI like that law. To avoid the kind of "social profiling" you describe you'd have to make sure that police don't have any incentive to make as much money as possible. Also, I suspect that rich people might sue and thus deter police from doing things like that.