4 ms·
I suspect she wasn't fined for downloading 24 songs but for distributing the songs to others. Still, that's an excessive fine. All legal systems that I know ar
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
I suspect she wasn't fined for downloading 24 songs but for distributing the songs to others. Still, that's an excessive fine.
All legal systems that I know are completely broken because the consequences of losing are so different for the parties involved. For that woman, losing the case means total financial ruin for the rest of her life. If the RIAA had lost, it would be just a blip in their legal budget if anything.
In my view, the right way to set fines would be to ask, what percentage of their profit have record companies lost due to the actions of that woman. She should be fined that same percentage of her disposable income (excluding minimum wage).
- nopassrecover 17y agoI agree. However, you need to take into account that the studio will allege that there must be greater punishment to deter the crime than just the cost. Even at double or triple percent it's not close though obviously.
- _pius 17y agoHowever, you need to take into account that the studio will allege that there must be greater punishment to deter the crime than just the cost. Even at double or triple percent it's not close though obviously. True. You'd think though that eventually good old-fashioned common sense would come into play. We have murderers who get punished more proportionally than this.
- netsp 17y agoA purpose of fines & other punishment is to .deter Very broadly speaking, two things go in to deterrence: (perceived) Chance of getting caught * (perceived) Cost of getting caught = deterence. To improve deterrence you need to increase one of these. There obviously isn't enough deterrence to stop illegal downloading/distribution. Higher fines are an easier option then more fines.
- joecode 17y agoThat would be a pretty good argument except for this woman's particular circumstances. She's a mother of 4 children and works at an Indian reservation. So chances are, she has very little disposable income, and wouldn't buy the songs otherwise. So what message is the RIAA trying to send by going after her? That they are ruthless bastards? They should go after people who can pay for the stuff.
- ErrantX 17y agoor that she needs teaching a lesson for takign things she cant afford (an important life lesson she apparently needs :))
- pmjordan 17y agoDefinitely. However, I don't see how financially destroying someone's life such that they might never recover from it is in any way a reasonable way to deal with a one-off copyright infringement on 2 dozen songs. My understanding is that she wasn't selling them or passing them off as her own.
- ErrantX 17y agoignoring the fine (it is excesive) the person I was replying to was inferring the RIAA should have chased her because she isn't well off. Which sounds like a poor argument to me :) She did need a lesson - not one quite so extreme but still.
- seertaak 17y ago> That would be a pretty good argument except for this woman's particular circumstances. Should her circumstances also be taken into account if she robs a bank? Justice is personified as being blind for a reason. You break the law, you pay the price. There's no: you broke the law, but factor X and Y should increase our leniency. That's a recipe for chaos I'm afraid.
- 17y ago
- radu_floricica 17y agoI happen to live in Romania, which (still) has lower income. I'm also freelancing right now and not very hard, so my income this year is lower still. So I could pretty much go up to your driveway, take your car, and if caught pay back $500 or less. Because of course this is what I can afford to pay. No, there is a much simpler way. She should pay to the order of magnitude of the loss she caused RIAA. A bit more actually, for deterrence. Which could be something like $1 for each song downloaded and $1 for an estimate of each song uploaded from her computer. This is not the real damage, because of course not every song downloaded would have been bought, but as an order of magnitude it's pretty much ok. You don't need to go counting incomes to make it right.
- seertaak 17y agoWell said. And if you're going down the "justice not blind" route, why even stop at income? "Your honour, I may have just killed a man but let me assure you that my high school years were very traumatic. I was bullied and got bad grades."
- furyg3 17y agoYou're confused. We're talking about monetary compensation to another party (damages) in a civil court, not a criminal murder case. This may save some embarrassment in the future: http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/60793/civil_criminal_court_cases_the_differences.html http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/60793/civil_crimina...
- seertaak 17y agoSorry, it is indeed you who is confused. My point is that the law treats all individuals equally. Your link was interesting, but nowhere therein did I see any mention of this basic tenet changing when we move from a criminal to a civil case. Justice is portrayed as a blind person for a reason; and it doesn't matter an iota if you're talking about civil or criminal law. And, in any case, the comment I was replying to used the example of car theft, which manifestly would involve a criminal case. My analogy is perfectly valid; it is you who ought be emabarrassed!