4 ms·
I'm not convinced that's "replication" in the sense that's important in science. Bugs in the original test will be reproduced in the attempted reproduction. I
by dllthomas 13y ago
I'm not convinced that's "replication" in the sense that's important in science. Bugs in the original test will be reproduced in the attempted reproduction. It's useful for "this person didn't flat out lie about their results", which is probably also a good thing, and for finding issues when replication fails, so I don't disagree that it should happen. I just disagree with calling it "replication".
- abecedarius 13y agoFair enough -- maybe we should find a different word. It's a reasonable bare minimum standard in the computing world, where it's practical: it makes it possible to trace back from questions and problems with the claim.
- dllthomas 13y agoSure - it's clearly a good idea, where feasible (and git repo + whatever-special-hardware should allow the same thing, for the one reasonable case I can think of where it wouldn't be feasible).