7 ms·
The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
- arethuza 13y agoOk - now that we've had Ender's Game made into a pretty decent movie can we get Use of Weapons? :-) http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/05/11/sci_fi_poll/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/05/11/sci_fi_poll/
- yoshokatana 13y agoI would throw money at anyone who made a Culture movie (as ironic as that action would be). Also, what about a Vorkosigan movie? Though I think it'd actually work pretty well as a TV show, with either hour-long episodes (one per book) or even with 2-4 shorter episodes per book.
- arethuza 13y agoThe scene where Zakalwe visits the Ethnarch Kerian could make a splendid "cold open" introducing the Culture and Zakalwe in a suitably dark fashion....
- triplesec 13y agoI am curious as to how there are no Culture films
- arethuza 13y agoMaybe a tagline of "Drug taking communists in space!" puts potential backers off? ;-) As far as I know the only people who seem keen on the works of Mr Banks are the BBC (TV version of The Crow Road and a Radio 4 version of the Culture in The State of the Art).
- grownseed 13y agoHaving read most of the other Culture novels, I'm actually reading this one at the moment, a fantastic read so far. I love the Culture novels, the universe that comes with it and all the intricate societal considerations. I've been thinking about, hell, craving for a screen adaptation of the Culture novels, though instead of a movie, I think it should probably be a show. It'd have to be really well done, there are a lot of things to take into account and I'm afraid a lot of TV producers/writers might cheapen it. I'm thinking the likes of HBO might be able to pull off something like that. I remember Iain M. Banks saying he was really worried about how TV writers might represent the ships, among other things, and I can totally get that. I can't find the source for this now, sorry, I thought it was in this http://nuwen.net/culture.html http://nuwen.net/culture.html (amazing read by the way), but a quick scan didn't bring it up.
- mikeash 13y agoI don't think UoW would make a good movie. It's a fantastic book, but it would have to be extremely long to capture everything needed for a movie, and I still don't think it would work well. For one thing, how could you capture the confusion that leads to the final twist in film? I think Consider Phlebas would be the one to go for. It has just about everything you could want for a fun action movie, but it's also smart. I recall Banks saying that he saw Star Wars and decided he could do better, and that's where CP came from, so it's a pretty natural fit. It's also quite a bit less serious than UoW and as a result I think it could stand being shaved down to movie length.
- arethuza 13y agoBelieve me, I'd be as happy as anyone if someone did a movie of Consider Phlebas (maybe Luc "5th Element" Besson?). :-) Pretty much every time I hear Coldplay's Paradise a trailer for Consider Phlebas plays in my mind.
- deletes 13y agoIf you haven't read the book first, DO SO, it is worth it.
- baldfat 13y agoI also don't know how the ending could be half as good as the book? Also I feel like I spoil the whole thing by saying the ending is good because when you read it with that knowledge you might get let down. Strange the BEST ending totally ruined by having an expectation of a awesome ending.
- nodata 13y agoI don't agree. I think if I'd read the book as a teenager, I would have loved it. As an adult reading the book for the first time, it's nothing special.
- moron4hire 13y agoIt is something special, though. If you read it, you realize where the Bush Administration's foreign policy came from. And by extension, the Obama Administration's foreign policy. I likewise did not enjoy the book as an adult reader. I thought it was far to apologetic for ultraviolent, genocidal overreactions to be considered healthy reading for teenagers. The end of the book is not "genocide is bad". It's "isn't is a shame that poor Ender had to be tricked into committing genocide?" It's not that "governments shouldn't be given the sort of power capable of genocide", it's that "you can get away with it scott-free if your intentions were good." Also, the whole "they hate me because I'm the best" wore really thin on me. It's just not a thing you see amongst real kids. In fact, being good at things is a good way to get other kids to like you. The kids didn't like Ender because he was a self-righteous prick, a spoil-sport punk with a Napoleon complex. The dialog also sucked. Grade A shitty dialog. As a teenager, you might be intrigued by the idea of alternative slang (and that is probably why Buffy the Vampire Slayer was so popular, and by extension why Joss Whedon has such a following now, but can't seem to follow it up). But as an adult, it is really annoying.
- rcfox 13y ago
- danso 13y agoReading this article made me impulsively buy the book again, except this time for Kindle (hard to pass up for $4). I think the last time I read it was as a young adult. Reading it now, it's still as gripping, but I wonder how much of our ageism - particularly in the tech industry - has to do with reading young-adult books not only in which the hero is very young, but that the ability to be "The One" is detected at an early age and in which anyone even in their teens is already past their prime (same goes for Star Wars)? I say "tech industry" because many of us grew up loving sci-fi books more than the average kid. It's no fault of the authors, because of course to be appealing to young adults, the young adults have to be the saviors.
- zacharydanger 13y agoI think as we age, we need to stop seeing ourselves as the Luke Skywalkers and more as the Ben Kenobis.
- talmand 13y agoToo bad it turns out that Obi-Wan wasn't the brightest guy. I like to view myself as more Chewbacca or R2-D2, since they are the only ones that seem to have their minds set right. Except for that one time R2 was memory-wiped, but even then...
- arethuza 13y ago"The oldest and most common Super Hero Origin. The easiest way to turn an Ordinary High School Student into the only thing preventing The End of the World as We Know It" http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheChosenOne http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheChosenOne
- baldfat 13y agoWell this would be middle school
- baldfat 13y agoYou NEED to read the "Shadow of Ender." It is the retelling of the whole story but through the eyes of a different character EXTREMELY well done.
- theorique 13y agoRemarkable book. I remember coming across the book as a teenager, having vaguely heard of it as 'good', and then staying up until 5 AM reading it. I can think of no more than a couple other books that had this effect on me.
- mathattack 13y agoIt's definitely a 1-sitting book. Don't pick it up if you have any responsibilities the next day.
- jazzyb 13y agoWow. How true. I started reading this book in college one night right before bed (~8 or 9). I finished it at 4am. I had no idea this book had a similar effect on others.
- gambiting 13y agoI perceive it as one of the worst Sci-Fi books that I have ever read. It's not a very popular opinion though, with the book being widely regarded as classic.
- theorique 13y agoI don't know that it's "great SF literature" in the sense of a Lord of The Rings or a Neuromancer, but it seems to hit people of a certain age in a certain emotional place. OSC managed to capture something about that experience that resonates with people. I'm curious to know, what did you dislike about the book?
- gambiting 13y agoIt maybe that I have read it as an adult for the first time,so I could neither sympathize,not find the idea of a brilliant 11 year old running an army particularly believable. I hated the idea of polarizing the world between the "good" US and the "bad" countries of the Warsaw Pact, even though I can see that it was a popular sentiment at the time. I did not like the dialogues, did not like any of the characters(maybe apart from Ender's sister,but even she was annoying at times). I could not sympathize with any of the issues in that book,nor stand for any of its ideas. I really wanted to stop reading halfway through, but forced myself to finish it to have a full picture of it. Having said that, I can still see why someone who read it as a child would like it - but it does not make it good overall. Just because I've read and loved the first Harry Potter book when it came out,does not mean it's a brilliantly written story, because it's not - it's interesting,but it's not well written. And I feel like this is the same issue with this book.
- mmuro 13y agoAt the end of the audiobook, Card talks at length about the difficulties getting an Ender's Game movie made. One problem was that the studios always wanted to make Ender an older teenager and to give him a love interest. Another was that the screenplay was always challenging because most of the book takes place inside Ender's head. Once he figured out that he could tell Ender's thought processes through Bean, it finally opened up the screenplay.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zequel 13y agoReminds me of the movie Watchmen, they said that was unfilmable as well. It was probably a tougher screenplay to write imo. e: grammar
- Pxtl 13y ago... I think the movie that came out of Watchmen is pretty much proof of the conjecture that it was unfilmable. The director tried very hard to be faithful to the original - the changes were minor (some added ultra-violent fight scenes, and changing the nature of the SQUID) but the film that came out just wasn't very good. Some of the cast chewed the scenery a bit harder than was strictly necessary, but no film is going to have perfect acting. And yet somehow it just was such a mess. A shame, since I loved Moore's book. Watchmen is a book that's designed to be read over and over and your own pace, with more to notice each time through. I think everybody skims the Black Freighter stuff the first time. Comics are so short that a good re-reading experience is prettymuch intrinsic to separating a decent comic from an excellent one. That doesn't really translate to film, since all the details and layers of the story just make the movie feel too dense.
- talmand 13y agoAlthough I respect your opinion, I highly disagree. In fact, many of your problems with the film are some of the things I actually liked about it.
- Pxtl 13y agoYou misunderstand my point. I'm saying that the actual specific divergencies and problems with the film that fans of the book can easily spot - the music, the small plot changes, and the acting - those aren't big problems. They're small problems that are easy to get past. But as a whole, the movie is a mess even though there's nothing you can put your finger on as "see here? this is where they ruined Moore's vision!". That's what I mean. The movie is a great and faithful attempt, but it still had a weak outcome. The book is unfilmable.
- 13y ago
- meunier 13y agoI strongly encourage everyone to abstain from buying the book or seeing the movie. You're lining Orson Scott Card's bigoted pockets to oppress sexual minorities.
- VaedaStrike 13y agoUnderstand his words in context before judging- http://www.hatrack.com/misc/Quotes_in_Context.shtml http://www.hatrack.com/misc/Quotes_in_Context.shtml
- anatoly 13y agoPeople like you are far more dangerous, in our times, than Orson Scott Card could ever be.
- DanBC 13y agoWhy?
- anatoly 13y agoBecause of the mind-numbing tendency to politicize everything. Card's book and the movie have nothing to do with his bigoted views, and should stand or fall on their own. In fact, the book (and possibly the movie), with its strong moral stance that resonates with teenagers, is likely to spread far more good by encouraging its readers to think about bullying, suffering of others, etc. than Card could possibly do harm, even if he wanted to, with its proceeds. Historically, just about every famous writer has been bigoted about something; all of us are probably bigoted in some ways in which future generations will judge us. If the sanctimonious boycott calls leveled against Card succeeded in the past, we'd be left without many wonderful masterpieces that enrich our lives and deepen our understanding.
- daughart 13y agoBecause pro-gay-rights activists have so much blood on their hands compared to homophobes and bigots. Oh right, it's the other way around. In America, a "vote" with a wallet means as much as a vote with a ballot.
- Pxtl 13y agoYou'd think the success of the Harry Potter franchise would've gotten that project fast-tracked. Kids love the story of a poor downbeaten kid turning out to be The Chosen One.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VaedaStrike 13y agoRead the man's actual quotes in context prior to judging the man. http://www.hatrack.com/misc/Quotes_in_Context.shtml http://www.hatrack.com/misc/Quotes_in_Context.shtml