2 ms·
Agreed, it's bunk. The reason you have modular designs is precisely because some parts aren't good enough so you need to be able to swap in better ones. When al
by simonh 13y ago
Agreed, it's bunk. The reason you have modular designs is precisely because some parts aren't good enough so you need to be able to swap in better ones. When all the parts are good enough, and are going to stay good enough, modularity offers insufficient advantages.
The thing with software is that you can have your cake and eat it. App platforms are intrinsically modular - every app is a little module of functionality. Looked at that way, the Apple ecosystem is staggeringly modular, with hundreds of thousands of modules available from many thousands of developers.
It's possible what Christensen means by modularity is really commoditisation. The idea that eventually base operating systems will be so mature and stable that it won't matter which one you're running, so there will be no reason to pay a premium for a proprietary system. I don't think that will ever be true. Human society, fashion, behaviour and needs are too dynamic and advancing too fast. OS and platform development has been going at breakneck speed for the entire history of computing and shows no signs of slowing down. Apple apparently 'lost' the PC wars because modular commoditised modular windows ate it's lunch. Yet now we live in a world where innovative mobile OSes, have totally redefined the computing experience and in the form of the iPad is chewing a great big hole back into the established computing market. The truth is that OSes were never commoditised and just good enough. It just looked that way because the stagnation of the dominant platform was misread as being stability.