3 ms·
> Taking H.264 to zero price is a net public good and a prerequisite for getting RF licensing of part or all of H.264 for all desktop systems (since rents there
by ZeroGravitas 13y ago
> Taking H.264 to zero price is a net public good and a prerequisite for getting RF licensing of part or all of H.264 for all desktop systems (since rents there, as opposed to on mobile devices, are running low).
More realistically, this just lets them have an escape valve for the one area that was likely to rock the boat, while not impacting their revenue at all (likely increasing it in fact).
It's a standard cartel move, which they already used by charging TV networks, and pay TV on the web, but carving out exceptions for video porn ("any paid video under 12 minutes") and the web. How exactly this gets sold as "non-discriminatory" I don't know, but then I don't understand how moving a file across a network can trigger payments for patents on the encoder used to produce it either.
It's a tricky subject, but I don't think allowing monopolies to price discriminate can be described as a "net public good" in the same that say, not allowing monopolies could be.
I understand the compromise, I'd prefer it if Mozilla fully understood it too.
edit: I just realised that by "a prerequisite for getting RF licensing of part or all of H.264" you're probably referring to the ongoing effort (started before H.264 was even begun) to get H.264 Baseline under proper RF terms, rather than "getting the blob for free" which is how I first took it. It would certainly be nice, but it seems to have failed repeatedly over the years.
- BrendanEich 13y agoWe at Mozilla understand things like divide-and-conquer to achieve a uniformly public good just fine, thanks. Do you really insist on all or nothing at a given instant? That is not how Firefox took on IE and took back the web, restarting competition and standardization. Sorry, we aren't able to take on the patent system in full. Note that US "health care" cartels practice legal price discrimination, they are exempt from Robinson-Patman. Still, piecewise reform can make a net public good. On RF for some or all profiles, see my point about desktop rents. Time passes. Just because something did not work in the past does not mean it won't in changed future circumstances.