4 ms·
In essence, apart from 2, which wouldn't take too much hindsight to calculate, both items seem to be the work of a real expert in crypto. Not the ones that go
by raverbashing 13y ago
In essence, apart from 2, which wouldn't take too much hindsight to calculate, both items seem to be the work of a real expert in crypto.
Not the ones that go for the "proven" way "because NIST said so" or the "internet specialists" that cry wolf more often than not (and miss or even suggest security holes)
- maaku 13y agoNot really. The original bitcoin client did what was called direct-to-IP transactions, which didn't use hashed pubkeys, and which was vulnerable to man-in-the-middle attacks (oops). Bitcoin's ECDSA curve was chosen because it was one of the faster ones, not because of any NIST connection (a "real" cryptographer of the day would have probably advised against the secp256k1 curve used in bitcoin in favor of one of the NIST curves, or DJB's curve which is superior in just about every way.
- celticninja 13y agounless the "real" cryptographer knew about the NIST/NSA weakening of secp256r1
- maaku 13y agoMy point, perhaps too subtle, was that in 2009 there was not sufficient public evidence to suggest such weakening. Rather, the reigning opinion (supported by historical evidence) was that NIST/NSA routinely strengthened standards by selecting parameters so as to make the algorithm secure against publicly unknown mathematical attacks. That is, after all, their stated purpose and what they did with the DES S-boxes. Turns out, the NSA is a shadow of its former self. But you'd have to have had non-public insider information to have known that with confidence in 2009.
- pbsd 13y agoWhat weakening, may I ask?
- geofft 13y ago1 is a little hokey because in the common case, the hash is just a weakness -- it doesn't add any security against classical computers, for which ECDSA is already hard enough, and it opens the possibility of hash collisions. I say "common case" because it only really is a win if _both_ quantum computers are in use _and_ you've never spent from the wallet and never will (except possibly to cash out entirely).