5 ms·
You can still by supplemental insurance, so they aren't regulating what you can have, they are regulating the minimum floor.
by cma 13y ago
You can still by supplemental insurance, so they aren't regulating what you can have, they are regulating the minimum floor.
- drivingmissm 13y agoObamacare is not a "minimum floor" it is a full suite of mandated coverage for every politically connected medical sector.
- dragonwriter 13y agoYes, its a minimum floor. And there are many plans that offer more than the ACA minimum. You may not like where the minimum is set, but that doesn't make it anything but a minimum floor.
- RickHull 13y ago> they aren't regulating what you can have, they are regulating the minimum floor. This is utter nonsense on its face. If I have (or want) something under the minimum floor, they have regulated that away from me. They have regulated what I can have.
- VladRussian2 13y agoThey also regulated away spoiled beef in stores, non smoke detectors equipped bedrooms and poisoned tap water. You can't have it. Minimum floor.
- RickHull 13y agoIndeed. I'm simply asking that we call a spade a spade.
- mrschwabe 13y agoSome municipalities mandate the addition of sodium fluoride in their public water systems. Sodium fluoride is a poison, so it's not necessarily accurate to claim they have 'regulated away' poisoned tap water.
- Aloisius 13y agoNo one drinking publicly fluoridated tap water in the US is coming even close to a toxic dose. You might as well call all caffeinated beverages toxic given the toxic dose of caffeine is 1/30th that of sodium fluoride.
- aric 13y agoThe difference is that said municipalities mandate that this toxic substance be added to people's water. With soda, people have more direct awareness and choice. With communal water, many people remain trusting and assuming. Meanwhile, there is no hard, double-blind science backing any clear benefits of fluoridation; yet the negatives keep growing. The EPA lowers their "recommended maximum" continually throughout the years, as pressure for sanity builds. Sane countries banned fluoridation long ago. Furthermore, the more it infects the food chain, the more "a little bit" adds up. It doesn't magically stay contained in tap water alone. Sure, it won't matter to most people, even not on principle alone. It will matter to some people, though, in compounding their chronic health problems. And that matters to me. Then there is ethics. Ethics and choice matter. Even if there were startling net benefits to this very toxic substance, using or ingesting it should be exclusively on an individual basis: personal choice, OTC, or per a physician. Advocating for needlessly and forcefully "medicating" (read: it's not medicine) other people through their communal water supply is, in no uncertain terms, blatantly unethical. It seems to stem from either psychopathy, greed, or sheer ignorance. It's on the same order as an industry and some physicians promoting nicotine cigarettes for health, once upon a time, and other such barbarities of an era.
- maxerickson 13y agoMost things that are considered to be medicine are pretty toxic. It's the dose that makes them into medicine. Some of this is because to be a medicine, a substance sort of needs to have a noticeable effect on our biology.
- aric 13y agoI appreciate your comment. You caught my conventional language and prodded me. I should be more careful. Toxicity is a factor of everything in medical science involving substances. ...in life rather. Medicine of all various forms is vast, highly varying per person, often contradictory over time in understanding, and constantly evolving. Conventionally, I consider medicine to be [something that is beneficial down to the personal level]. I'll rephrase. It isn't good medicine. Fluoride treatments and water fluoridation are medicines like mercury treatment was once medicine. Explicit forms of "medication" must be relegated solely to an individual's active consent when consent is possible. That means a conscious choice to partake in the "medicine," on or in one's body, without medicating other people in the treatment. That's basic ethics. The benefit:negative ratio would have to be astronomically high to justify any less standard where medicine is concerned. Medicine is very personal. Speaking for myself, when an extremely toxic substance to humans, no matter the dose, is intentionally added to something as important as water and thus a food chain, it has already lost the ethical equation. Massively "medicating" passive "patients" through the water supply is just sad. Worse still, ingesting fluoride hasn't been justified on any beneficial, medical level -- and quite the opposite with negatives. Thus, it's hard for me to associate the term "medicine" with it. I completely concede to that point though.
- Turing_Machine 13y agoSpoiled beef is quite a different thing from requiring a 60 year old man to buy maternity coverage.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoYou mean spreading the cost of maternity coverage across all policyholders. Perhaps you're not aware of how insurance works, spreading risk and all that jazz. Have healthcare system where costs are externalized? People complain. Have healthcare system where costs are internalized and properly accounted for? People complain.
- Turing_Machine 13y ago1) You don't get to tell me what I "mean". 2) I'm quite aware of how insurance works. Please do share with us the probability of a 60 year old man becoming pregnant, then explain why that "risk" needs to be "spread".
- ncarroll 13y agoI wonder what the probability of a 60 year old man getting his lovely partner pregnant might be? That looks like a reason for spreading risk to me.
- Turing_Machine 13y agoGiven that the law also requires the lovely partner to have her own coverage, I think your "reason" is dubious at best.
- Turing_Machine 13y agoAlso note that the law requires 60 year old women to buy maternity coverage. Is their lovely partner going to make them pregnant? Given that the Guinness record for the oldest natural conception is 59, I think not (there are a few cases of older women giving birth, but those all involved in vitro fertilization or the like). What other astoundingly unlikely events do you guys think people should be required to insure against? Meteor impact? Virgin birth? All the molecules of air rushing to one side of the room and suffocating you?