3 ms·
> There are any number of processes that will occur easily in one direction, but can have... dramatic... results in the other direction. Consider, by analogy, b
by anamax 17y ago
> There are any number of processes that will occur easily in one direction, but can have... dramatic... results in the other direction. Consider, by analogy, breaking H2O into hydrogen and oxygen, vs. recombining them.
Ooh, dramatic. Except that the issue is irreversible.
You can split and combine hydrogen and oxygen repeatedly and the same thing happens every time.
We don't see evidence of dramatic effects from the last time CO2 levels were high and went down. (We also don't see evidence of the predicte runaway temperatures either, but I digress.)
If you're going to argue that this time will be different, shouldn't you have something better than "we don't know"?
Yes, we might see species changes. However, niches don't stay empty. And, the claim was "irreversible temperature changes".
- CWuestefeld 17y ago> Yes, we might see species changes. And, the claim was "irreversible temperature changes". Ahh, I think I expressed myself badly. I didn't mean that temperatures could return, period (although on second reading, my text does convey that). I meant that things couldn't be reversed as in a movie being played backwards, returning things to their original state. I think we're actually in agreement, but talking past each other due to my poor initial phrasing.
- anamax 17y ago> I meant that things couldn't be reversed as in a movie being played backwards, returning things to their original state. Even if aliens took all of the "excess" CO2 out of the atmosphere tomorrow, manipulated the climate so it was always 1969 weather-wise (because that's the definition of perfection), and gave us an endless supply of dilithium crystals, things 10 years from now would be different than they are today. Change always happens. The relevant question is good vs bad. (I don't see how one can assume that new species will necessarily be bad.)