6 ms·
Alan Kay’s reading list
- jacobolus 17y agoI prefer this to any of the similar lists I’ve found around the web (e.g. the one discussed at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=663662 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=663662 ). Nearly everything from this list that I am familiar with is wonderfully insightful.
- michael_nielsen 17y agoThis was posted 18 months ago (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=92007 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=92007 ). No problem with a repost - this is an absolutely wonderful list of books - just mentioning it because there are a couple of interesting comments on the earlier posting.
- michael_nielsen 17y agoIt's striking how broadly engaged Kay is with the world. He finds ideas, problems and inspiration everywhere. To know how to write a program, all you need to know is APIs, algorithms, and tools. But to design breakthrough software - to know what program to write - it obviously helps to also be broadly engaged with the world.
- jacobolus 17y agoSome part of this is that Kay is more concerned with cognition and learning, and especially in children, than he is with computer programming as such. Programming happens to be a uniquely exciting way to engage with mathematics, and computers happen to be wonderful tools in many types of learning, so he has devoted of his career to inventing programming environments and interfaces for kids. Because all programming – even to some extent pure numerical algorithm design/optimization – is an exercise in communication and human-usable abstraction, most programmers should probably spend more time on developmental psychology than they do currently.
- david927 17y agoI think he understands many things we'll only recognize much later, and one of these is that kids need clarity. (Not simplicity; people talk down to kids all the time.) And clarity is orthogonality, it's structure, it's everything we need in our funny little industry and nothing we have. There are 20 people I admire in this field and the first seven are Alan Kay.
- dca 17y agoI find it also striking how long he's been like that. He's truly an icon.
- jodrellblank 17y agoOne thing I've been pondering lately, is the more general purpose of reading books. I used to read quite a lot of books, library books and personal books. Mostly fiction and popular science, I hesitate to admit (not hesitate to read them, just hesitate to admit because they are 'lesser' books). There are a lot of things that I couldn't tell you whether I have read or not, let alone what the main points were. Now I mostly read online and read pages every day that are forgotten within hours. Every day or two I find somethings really interesting and hold onto those ideas for a while, but they fade. How many great ideas did I read from Kathy Sierra? Lots... I think. As long as you don't ask what they were. Am I really doing this just to feel good about saying "I've read that!"? Am I reading for the occasional "ooh, I read something interesting about that once... where was it?" feeling of contribution? Am I missing something fundamental about reading and remembering that other people get - ought I to be studying books instead of skimming them? Ought I to remember more of the content? Am I really a better person for having read more books? For having been exposed to certain ideas?
- jacobolus 17y agoPersonally, I find that I remember much better with a pen in hand. If you've really engaged with a work – scribbled all over the margins, written a review, discussed it with your friends – you're much less likely to forget either its insights or your own reactions.
- michael_nielsen 17y agoI wrote a little flashcard script that lets me enter and later test myself on facts. If I get the answer to a question right, the delay before a repeat of the question increases. If I get the answer wrong, the delay decreases. When I read something I want to remember, I just enter a bundle of relevant questions into the program. It's helped a lot with retaining knowledge.
- emmett 17y agoReading books is mostly something you do for entertainment, like going to the movies, or eating nice food. There's nothing wrong with that! It's very pleasurable, and occasionally useful. But generally most reading doesn't make you a better person, any more than watching opera or other "high" art does.
- Alex3917 17y agoHas anyone here actually read Piaget? I've heard that he was such a bad writer that even his closest disciples often had no idea what he was talking about. I'm tempted to read these books, but on the other hand I'm worried it will make it even harder to understand his ideas.
- omouse 17y agoHere you go: http://books.google.com/books?id=jJZ7aWY4tIcC&printsec=frontcover&dq=inauthor:%22Jean+Piaget%22&ei=Lt86SrfoKqDcMLmi7bgF http://books.google.com/books?id=jJZ7aWY4tIcC&printsec=f... Some pages you can read to see if you understand his writing.
- Alex3917 17y agoThanks for the link. Yeah, it's even worse than I'd imagined. I think I'll stick to just reading Duckworth's summaries of his ideas for now.
- b-man 17y agoIf you want an advice, read Seymour Papert's articles and books (http://www.papert.org/works.html http://www.papert.org/works.html, also take a look at http://learning.media.mit.edu/content/publications/EA.Piaget%20_%20Papert.pdf http://learning.media.mit.edu/content/publications/EA.Piaget...) Papert's style is very accessible, and he was, at least in my view (and in Piaget's view) the guy who grok his ideas the most.
- Alex3917 17y agoThanks, I'll check these out.
- GHFigs 17y agoI second the recommendation of Papert. The first few chapters of Mindstorms are extremely accessible and probably more relevant to any HN reader than anything direct from Piaget.
- dhess 17y ago
- quizbiz 17y agoDoes anyone know of any article/essay length readings that one can read in one sitting of on par quality?
- jballanc 17y agoOh man...I was totally with him until I saw "Selfish Gene". Please, speaking as an evolutionary biologist, don't read that book. Dawkins oversimplifies the important and complicates the obvious. If you want a good book on an analytical approach to evolution, might I recommend "Evolutionary Dynamics" by Nowak in its place.
- 10ren 17y agoThe "Selfish Gene" seemed well-written to me, though I'm not an evolutionary biologist. I would appreciate it if you could note down a couple of things he oversimplified or complicated, please.
- jballanc 17y agoHeh... unfortunately, I've been very busy, and a thorough look into everything that's wrong with "Selfish Gene" would require more time than I have. It is well written, and that's one of the problems with the book, and Dawkins in general. That is, many people are willing to accept his views because they are well written and do not take the time (or have the background) to question their scientific validity. For starters, very early on Dawkins acknowledges the current lack of consensus as to the exact definition of a "gene" (i.e. does it include promoter/enhancer/other regulatory sequences? should each polymorphism count as one gene? or do we group them together? and if so where, in the continuum of small differences between "genes" do we draw the line?). His proposed solution is to take as a gene any combination of genetic elements which gives rise to an expressed trait. He then expands on this basic definition to describe how it leads to genes which are "selfish". That is, they are interested only in their own continuance, and so the traits they code for will be optimized around this goal. Unfortunately, this is dangerously close to circular logic. You see, the physical traits that appear in organisms rarely have a simple one-to-one correspondence with a particular subset of the genome. Effects such as epistasis, where the action of one gene masks the effect of another, nullify Dawkins' simplistic definition. Or, if you would have it another way, genes which have epistatic effects would need to be included in with the original "gene" according to Dawkins' definition. Unfortunately, the network effects that give rise to higher plants and animals would eventually necessitate including the entire genome of an organism in one "Dawkins gene", making the unit of selection not the gene, as Dawkins would have it, but the individual. As for topics which he over-complicates, the first that comes to mind is kin selection. Admittedly, I don't think his over-complication is intentional, but rather his exploration of the topic is hindered by his presumption that genes are selfish. In fact, kin selection can arise in evolving individuals without the need for the concept of a "gene" at all! Rather, any evolving individual which evolves in a mixed population will eventually acquire various kin selection traits. As I said at the start, I'm not surprised that Dawkins' ideas are so commonly held as true. He is well written, and most of the work that would refute his claims is usually presented in language inaccessible to most laypeople.
- steveeq1 17y agoRead Lateral Thinking. I saw it on his list and read it. Very good for teaching you how to think outside the box.
- gabeybaby 17y agoThere goes my next four weekends. Damn you!