17 ms·
> It's hard not to come to the conclusion that these activities were essentially criminal. I don't see how the administration can fail to disavow them, investig
by bradleyjg 13y ago
> It's hard not to come to the conclusion that these activities were essentially criminal. I don't see how the administration can fail to disavow them, investigate them fully, and hold their instigators accountable. It feels like Special Prosecutor time.
The government takes the position that their agents are almost completely unconstrained by law when it comes to actions taken abroad aimed at non-US persons.
Even were a court somewhere to find that this interpretation is incorrect, there are numerous "good faith reliance" doctrines that prevent any prosecution or even civil consequences.
The government outright tortured people for years, and nothing has come of it. No prosecutions. No damages for victims. No cases dismissed for outrageous government conduct. Not even very many harsh words from judges. The only people for whom there were any consequences were the low level regular army people who got in on the torture train without first getting official blessing.
It'll be the same thing here. If some low level employee went out on his own to hack into Google servers, something might come of it. But by all appearances these programs were deliberate, planned, and vetted. In those circumstances the bad actors have long since learned to cover their own asses. There will be no consequences for them.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> actions taken abroad aimed at non-US persons. And there is an interesting counterpoint to that, e.g. > "If the Americans eavesdropped on cellphones in Germany, they broke German law on German soil, and those responsible must be held accountable." http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/10/28/world/obama-unaware-as-u-s-spied-on-merkel-officials/ http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/10/28/world/obama-unaw...
- bradleyjg 13y agoThe problem is that the people who were actually in Germany breaking German law were (likely) on diplomatic passports and so have plenary immunity. Meanwhile, under international law, which German courts take seriously even if US courts do not, senior state officials have functional immunity for actions taken in an official capacity with a disputed exception for violations of jus cogens+. While there may be some room between the people on the ground who are immune and the senior officials who are immune to prosecute mid-level functionaries, that's not terribly satisfying and there still remains the problem of getting them in front of the court. See generally: http://www.lawfareblog.com/2013/10/the-nsa-affair-goes-criminal-in-germany/#more-28159 http://www.lawfareblog.com/2013/10/the-nsa-affair-goes-crimi... +The most serious types of international norms: things like genocide, slavery, torture, and piracy.
- swombat 13y agoTypically, if a diplomat constantly breaks the laws of the nation they're sent to in this manner, they get kicked out, and if the sender country in question keeps sending this sort of diplomat, the embassy would eventually be closed.
- a3n 13y agoI cannot imagine Germany closing the US Embassy.
- swombat 13y agoYeah, it's not like the German people are at all sensitive about the topic of having a secret, unaccountable organisation spying on them.
- gdwatson 13y agoI certainly can't blame them for being upset. But for a NATO country to expel the US embassy would be a very dramatic act with uncertain consequences. There's a lot of fallout to accept there, and the impact would be broader than US-German relations.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> for a NATO country to expel the US embassy would be a very dramatic act with uncertain consequences. Absolutely, but when German Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich says "those responsible must be held accountable." I would guess that he means that there will, must be consequences. Closing the embassy is a consequence of last resort, if there is continued intransigence. Will that happen? that's up to the US government, and possibly not the elected part.
- a3n 13y agoAs we're learning here in the US, there's a big difference and gap between "the people" and the government.
- spdy 13y agoThey did not break German Law. Germany still has past WWII contracts with the Allied Nations in certain areas. http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=de&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sueddeutsche.de%2Fpolitik%2Fhistoriker-foschepoth-ueber-us-ueberwachung-die-nsa-darf-in-deutschland-alles-machen-1.1717216 http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=de&tl=en&u=ht...
- brown9-2 13y agoAll espionage that Country A does in Country B is illegal in Country B. That's why it's espionage.
- jlgreco 13y agoYou are missing the "and therefore there it is unreasonable for you to be upset" leap. Pointing out that illegal things are illegal isn't really a interesting contribution to the discussion, is it? I assume that wasn't all you meant to do.
- DannyBee 13y ago"The government takes the position that their agents are almost completely unconstrained by law when it comes to actions taken abroad aimed at non-US persons. " It's worse than this. You also generally can't sue the US government civilly unless they allow you to. US has abrogated sovereign immunity in certain situations for certain types of torts, but ..
- bradleyjg 13y agoCivil immunity is a subset of completely unconstrained by law. For example, judges are entitled to absolute civil immunity for actions taken in an official capacity. But they have occasionally been charged criminally for actions for which they were civilly immune.
- DannyBee 13y ago"Civil immunity is a subset of completely unconstrained by law" Sorry, I didn't read it that way :) Since the original thread seemed to be about criminalness, I assumed you meant they could not be charged criminally for their actions. There is a huge difference, as you point out, between civil and criminal liability.
- bostonpete 13y ago> actions taken abroad aimed at non-US persons. Aren't Google and Yahoo US persons? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood#Corporations_as_persons_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood#Corporatio...
- unreal37 13y agoActually, if I were Google or Yahoo, I would be getting my lawyers to prepare some type of lawsuit. Not that I think it will succeed, but Google/Yahoo are direct victims here.
- bilbo0s 13y agoWell... given the game the leakers are playing with these documents... I would wait before I made any definitive statements about who is a victim and who is a villain. The release of these documents seem to be carefully timed and calculated to give the government, corporations and people involved in the surveillance state the time and latitude to incriminate themselves. Not only are the Government, the corporations and the people involved trying to tell a story... clearly the leakers are trying to tell a story as well. Are we at the climax of the leakers' plot? or are we still building? I think it might be best to get a look at all the cards first... and then decide what happened.
- unreal37 13y agoFair enough.
- mpyne 13y agoDoesn't Google and Yahoo both operate shell companies overseas in order to avoid US taxes though?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> The government takes the position that their agents are almost completely unconstrained by law when it comes to actions taken abroad aimed at non-US persons. More to the point of the article here, the government takes the position that their agents are completely unconstrianed by law when it comes to using information shared by foreign intelligence services that their agents had no part in collecting, and the collection here is done by the GCHQ -- a British intelligence agency -- who simply provides NSA the privilege of submitting search terms and getting matching data from the collection GCHQ does from their taps.
- a3n 13y agoAnd yet we civilians are still liable for receiving stolen goods.
- danbruc 13y agoI am at a loss for words. Arrogant, self-righteous, disrespectful, ignorant, mendacious...nothing cuts it. It is illegal in the US but who cares about the rest of the world? I can not remember when something similar made me that angry as the current conduct of the US does. If I would not know better that this would negatively affect the whole world and innocent US citizens and that emotional reactions are usually not good - I would just cut all cables to the US, stop all trades of oil, raw material and goods, deny US citizens to enter any foreign country and then just do your shit over there and get happy with it. EDIT: Just to clarify it a bit more, I am not primarily angry because of the spying - read my mails if it makes you happy. What really pisses me of is this sentiment of thinking of non-US citizens as second class humans. We are not spying at US citizens, only at this other guys across the ocean. And sadly this sentiment is also present in part of the media coverage. Especially when the story broke there was a lot of outrage about (accidentally) spying at US citizens, but spying at non-US citizens and breaking foreign law in peacetime is deemed acceptable.
- allochthon 13y agoI would just cut all cables to the US, ... deny US citizens to enter any foreign country and then just do your shit over there and get happy with it. Whoah, there. Your grievances are well-placed. But keep in mind that it's a certain subset of agencies in the US government that are responsible for the problems you're upset about, not all US citizens. As for fixing things, the government has become literally unmanageable, and things are a mess right now.
- fragsworth 13y ago> The government outright tortured people for years, and nothing has come of it. I am not saying it's OK, but in that case, most US citizens aren't even affected. In the case of surveillance, data from US citizens is being directly compromised. Their attempt to do what they want to foreign individuals with surveillance actually causes some collateral damage to US citizens.
- danbruc 13y agoWho cares about the collateral damage done to US citizens? The problem is the damage done to non-US citizens.
- gcb0 13y agoWhat?! since when non-us citzens can vote? remember that democracy (even half-implemented as it is in the US) is the dictatorship or the majority (that can vote).
- jlgreco 13y agoIf voters are concerned with the plight of non-voters, then the plight of non-voters is by definition of concern to voters. Asking voters to be concerned with what their government does to non-voters should never be discouraged. It may be futile, but it should not be discouraged.
- fragsworth 13y agoI only made the distinction because someone pointed out that it's difficult for government agencies to get in legal trouble unless US citizens are the ones being harmed.
- grecy 13y ago> I am not saying it's OK, but in that case, most US citizens aren't even affected. There is a very strong line of reasoning that says terrorist attacks and thousands of America soldiers killed in combat are a direct result of these kinds of foreign policies.
- spunky 13y agoMonroe Doctrine 2.0
- PeterisP 13y agoI'm sure the other branches of US government would be delighted if NSA would share with them - not the secret data, but their data processing tools. I mean, it appears that NSA has the ability to separate the retrieved gmail data into citizens and non-citizens, so they can legally use the non-citizen part of data and throw the 'forbidden' US-citizen data away. Think of the wonders that we could do with such technology! We wouldn't need passports anymore, when arriving from another country, you just provide your gmail account, TSA systems check that you're a citizen and lets you right in with a smile...