2 ms·
As somebody who attended college off and on, and in my 20s instead of right out of high school, I missed out on this. I think you're on to something there, Erra
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
As somebody who attended college off and on, and in my 20s instead of right out of high school, I missed out on this. I think you're on to something there, ErrantX.
I've been a fan of some required national service for some of these same reasons. I think not only you, but society as a whole benefits when young people are put together and form support groups as part of starting off. It should be encouraged more.
- ErrantX 17y agoYou also get to meet people across a diverse range of subjects. I imagine working on hacker type projects would be great fun - but everyone would likely very samey :) I like that I can ring up a friend for help on some obscure historical reference in pub quizes :P National Service; I'm totally down with that! Actually (slightly off topic) I've always been a fan of replacing young offenders institutes with something like enforced national service (the training stuff not the gun in hand stuff ;)). There was a great show here in the UK where they threw dossers into a "bad lads" national service camp and it had a real positive effect on them! I think both examples (NService and college life) are about pushing you out of any comfort zones :)
- dantheman 17y agoRequired National Service is a horrible idea, for a myriad of reasons -- #1 of which is that it's slavery. Notice how whenever anyone talks about national service, it's always aimed at the politically naive (children, and young adults). We don't see required national service for 35 year olds, or 60 year olds. Now supporting groups for young people to tackle is interesting problems (where they develop character and lasting relationships) is commendable, as long as its voluntary and not looking for a handout.
- ErrantX 17y agoIs there a middle ground? So for example I would be a fan of young people who left school and stay on the dole for several years (say 2 years) being made to do some form of service (maybe not military). It would certainly give them a boost IMO.
- dantheman 17y agoI don't understand why you want young people to stay on the dole for 2 years? Shouldn't they being doing something productive? I think that the constant age segregation throughout school and college is actually a major hindrance to most people. I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve, there are already programs for people that want structure (college, peace corps, military, volunteer work, etc).. I'd personally prefer to have them do something that delivers value, than doing something that makes them feel good but is ultimately wasteful. I also think its wrong to take money from others to subsidize programs that aren't available to them; think of the minimum wage worker whose taxes help send others to college while they're stuck trying to scrape by.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoYour post surprises me, because just a couple of days ago you told me you were a libertarian, and that suggests you would oppose all forms of slavery. Of course, you later added that you were a utilitarian, and you're certainly not the first utilitarian to favor some type of slavery. But I don't see how you can square this with the "libertarian" label.