5 ms·
Flamingo for Mac: A Modern Messaging App
- chm 13y agoGood looking, but it isn't immediately obvious why I should pay 10$ for it when software like Adium already does this perfectly well? I might have missed some crucial functionality.
- danpalmer 13y agoI just bought it, and I must say it is a very nice, slick, modern Mac app. I prefer it to chatting in Adium so far. That said, I would like it much more if it supported more services than just XMPP. Supporting the Adium service plugin API would actually be a really nice way of doing this (from a user's perspective), but if not, a new API would do well also.
- indragie 13y agoHi there, I'm the developer of Flamingo. This is something that I considered during the development process but with the Mac App Store, sandboxing, and the overall difficulty of designing a good plugin API, this didn't make the cut for 1.0. Once things stabilize a bit I'll have more time to experiment with things like this. It's only 1.0 :)
- danpalmer 13y agoHi, thanks for the response! When I first read the features, I assumed the Facebook/Hangouts and XMPP were essentially 3 different modules, which would probably make extending it to third party plugins fairly easy. But I realised that all of the services are XMPP at the moment, and therefore I suppose this would mean adding lots more abstraction to internal APIs and stuff. I've heard about issues with sandboxing and plugins before, but as far as I can tell they are mostly for when plugins need access to the filesystem, as they have a different bundle ID and therefore don't get permissions from the main application? I might be completely wrong there though. As long as the plugins for Flamingo don't need filesystem access, or other privileged access, I would have thought it would be fine. RapidWeaver, for example, has a large plugin community, but is distributed on the App Store.
- chrischen 13y agoThe other problem is I still have to keep Messages open (which does a lot of what this app does) because it can send iMessages to iPhones.
- bsg75 13y agoIf a demo was available one could determine it for themselves. This trend of demoless AppStore delivery is getting annoying.
- YooLi 13y agoVery nice looking application. Congratulations. Is there a buddy list or menu bar applet, or do you have to have the full app window open to see who is online? Also, I didn't see it mentioned in the list of supported services, but does this work with Apple iMessages?
- TheMakeA 13y agoLooks like just Facebook/Google Hangouts/XMPP is supported. You can undock chats from the main window and it acts sort of like a buddy list.
- TheMakeA 13y agoAwesome. I've been looking for something like this to replace Adium. While Adium is great, it feels nothing like an OS X app.
- serkanyersen 13y agoLooks very good and promising. However, I wouldn't pay $10 without at-least seeing the app in action. A trial app would be nice.
- rlm 13y agoDitto. And I'd also like group chats to be supported. But it is very pretty!
- danpalmer 13y agoI would usually agree, but I happened to have some App Store credit so took the plunge and bought it anyway. Fairly impressed so far, but Adium is much more of a power-user's tool, so this isn't necessarily the best replacement for it.
- tjosten 13y agoYou have to offer a trial at least. The app looks nice, and I would be willing to pay 10 bucks for it, but not before I tested it. So, your turn.
- imgs 13y ago+1
- monkey_slap 13y agoI'm assuming you can't use iMessage with this? Looks incredibly, but iMessage is a vital part of my workflow throughout the day. I also agree with others that $10 is a steep price without any form of a trial.
- wuster 13y agoUI is very nicely done, but to echo some other sentiments here, I'm not sure it's $10 better than Adium. At $5, I'd just buy it to support great OS X developers, as I want to encourage this type of effort.
- wereHamster 13y agoNo IRC?
- rlm 13y agoCheck out Textual: https://github.com/Codeux/Textual https://github.com/Codeux/Textual (No affiliation, just a happy user)
- Kudos 13y agoI for one don't feel the need for an all-in-one communication app. I'm happy to use an app like Textual for IRC and Flamingo for IM.
- imjoshdean 13y agoUnderstandable, some people do, some people don't. I'm one of those people who do. For $10, if this thing included IRC, I would switch over in a heart beat. If it also included SKYPE? Oh man, the things I would do to the developer who made it...that would be heaven. Less apps open usually means less memory consumption, and overall less clutter on my desktop.
- pencilcheck 13y agoI recommended LimeChat http://limechat.net http://limechat.net
- antr 13y agoIt looks really good, and I really like the media embedding feature. However, $10 for a desktop app with no trial option, no phone app (cross-platform), for me it is tough to click the buy button. Would love to see a "launch" blog post to see how CTR/funnel looks like after launching on HN. Best of luck!
- jd007 13y agoDoes it actually integrate with Google Hangout? I stopped using Adium and switched to the Google Hangout Chrome plugin because Adium did not fully integrate with Hangout (messages I read on Adium do not get marked as read on the Hangout app on my phone). Chrome Hangout plugin works but I'd like something native.
- danpalmer 13y agoNot that I can tell. I am fairly sure that it only supports Hangouts as far as the XMPP interface to it that Adium uses.
- jd007 13y agoYeah given that the new Hangouts is a proprietary closed protocol (as far as I know) I don't think it's possible for third party to fully integrate. Their site has the Hangout logo and says Hangout on the feature list which gave me a bit of hope. But if you scroll down it actually says it supports Google Talk instead of Hangout.
- danpalmer 13y agoYep, it is a closed API. A bit annoying, but I much prefer desktop clients over web applications or browser plugins, that's just personal preference though.
- jd007 13y agoYeah I do prefer desktop clients over web apps and browser plugins. But I do do not want to have to mark messages as read twice, once on my computer and again on my phone which is why I tolerate the Chrome Hangout plugin.
- prezjordan 13y agoBeen on the alpha for this for a few months, absolutely in love with it. Good-looking chat clients are hard to come by. Also, does all software require a free trial or something? I never got that memo.
- akmiller 13y ago"Also, does all software require a free trial or something? I never got that memo." Obviously no, but it's hard to convince people to move from software that works (such as Adium) to your software if you can't at least provide a great overview of how it works via video demonstration or better yet allowing the user to try it out.
- bdcravens 13y agoAll software doesn't require a price either. I think that you would agree that there are a number of features not present that many are used to, according to comments in this thread. Fewer sales due to a trial is far better than a one and two star reviews, which could conceivably sink a product before it could get off the ground.
- andyfleming 13y agoLooks nice, but AIM, and esepcially Bonjour chat are essential day-to-day for me. Skipping on this app for now.
- tannerc 13y agoLooks slick, as others have pointed out. However, if your primary value proposition is "a modern messaging app," you've lost a great opportunity to capture new customers. We already have modern messaging apps, plenty of them to boot. Why not change that up a bit to be customizable messaging, or the most elegantly powerful messaging on your Mac, or something more than just "modern" messaging? Looks neat, regardless.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eddieroger 13y agoI guess the gamble that the App Store spoiled us all in to abandoning our trials in favor of blind purchases is a bad one. In my mind, this app wants to replace Adium in my life, and while I'd like to let it try, I am also hesitant to throw $10 at a "maybe". If it were open to a trial, sure thing. The psychology of HN's shared response is probably worthy of a blog post.
- dhruvmittal 13y agoI'd bet that I'm a lot more cautious buying apps from the Mac App Store than I am from Google's Play Store, simply because Google's got that safety net of "Eh, this app isn't as good as it looked in the screenshots. I'll just return it." Trial periods also usually go a long way in convincing me to spend money on an app, especially things more costly than a dollar or two. A few months ago, I found myself debating between Totalfinder and Pathfinder- luckily, they both had a few weeks of free trials and I was able to determine that while pathfinder looked like it had more features, Totalfinder just felt a lot more seamless in day-to-day use. If I hadn't had the ability to sit down and get a feel for the apps, I'd probably have just said "fuck it, I don't need tabs and split panes that much anyways."
- indragie 13y agoWe're gauging the demand for a trial version at the moment and may decide to offer one if we find that many users are surprised by things not working as expected after purchasing the app (e.g. certain accounts not working, things that were unclear in the marketing, etc.)
- ubercore 13y agoTo add a data point, I'm not going to give a chat app (a small utility, but an important one that I'd be willing to pay for) a second thought at $10 without a trial.
- mfkp 13y agoI'm perfectly happy with Adium right now. If you want my $10, there better be a trial to convince me to switch.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 13y agoDoes it support OTR? Is it built on libpurple?
- danpalmer 13y agoAnother commenter said there is no OTR, however I can't find anything that says this specifically. It could be doing it entirely transparently. It doesn't appear to be using libpurple, it contains XMPPFramework (https://github.com/robbiehanson/XMPPFramework https://github.com/robbiehanson/XMPPFramework) instead.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cylo 13y agoAccording to the developer, OTR support is planned. Referenced here: https://twitter.com/FlamingoForMac/status/395268991985676289 https://twitter.com/FlamingoForMac/status/395268991985676289
- bluetidepro 13y agoFrom the FAQs: > "Where can I change my status? You can't and don't need to. Flamingo automatically updates your status between Available, Idle, Away, and Offline by monitoring the idle time of your computer. And status messages? Come on, it's 2013." ...I do not like that one bit. Saying it's 2013 is very ignorant to how people use the "away" feature. I like manually setting if I'm away or busy, because I'm working and do not want to be disrupted. I think you guys should re-think your understanding of how people use Available/Away/Idle/Etc.
- danpalmer 13y agoI never set this on my chat clients, and find it very annoying that it's not always done for me. I think this one is just a matter of opinion. Perhaps a setting for it would be nice in the future, but for 1.0, I think they made a good decision.
- MichaelGG 13y agoThere's a difference between cutting a feature due to resource constraints, and actively saying that the feature is a bad idea. Unless you're pulling an Apple/Microsoft and telling people they're wrong, while you hurry to do the right thing.
- Foomandoonian 13y agoI agree. If I don't want to be interrupted, I close down the client. I don't really see how this is much different to manually setting my status to 'busy'.
- Touche 13y agoAgreed, wouldn't have bought it if I had known that, I also like to change my status when busy.
- FireBeyond 13y agoRight. My company uses GTalk - we all work remotely - and it’s customary for us to use Busy with things like “On The Phone” or “Meeting” or whatever.
- egypturnash 13y agoLooks cute. Another vote for a trial of some kind. Not that I'm likely to switch from Adium to be honest; most of my friends are still on AIM.
- tobr 13y agoNice looking app, but why are those "Learn More"-links made out of fuzzy, poorly compressed jpegs? Doesn't exactly communicate attention to detail.
- joshuahornby 13y agoVery nice looking app. Although a feature I really think a lot of people need is a nice icon in the status bar. How else are we meant to know we have a message whilst glancing at our screens?
- patrickod 13y agoInstalled it and while it looks very nice it's been beachballing almost constantly with only 2 accounts connected (facebook and hangout) Search is very slow and causes ~500ms input lag. Needs a lot of polish still.
- jd007 13y agoDoes it fully integrate with Hangout? If you get a message and read it in the app, does your Hangout mobile app's notification badge disappear?
- indragie 13y agoWe're aware of performance issues with larger buddy lists (which tends to happen when Facebook accounts are connected) and an update will be submitted to the MAS soon that fixes this.
- dewey 13y ago"Flamingo does not support group chats in Facebook or Hangouts/Gtalk, and MUC (Multi User Chat) for XMPP is not supported." Unfortunately that'd be my main use case. I was looking forward to replacing the ugly Hangouts Chrome Plugin.
- angularly 13y agoPaid for is to replace messages because I hate how messages separates friends and message window. But I feel like I've been cheated out of 10$ because it says its compatible with Messages, but after I bought it I find out I can't add my Apple account and talk with all my friends who have ios devices, so exactly how he can claim its compatible with Messages is beyond me.
- indragie 13y agoWe claimed that Flamingo supports backward compatible file transfer with Messages and Adium users, not that we supported Apple accounts.
- ateevchopra 13y agoI really loved the design. Can you please send me the promo code so i can try it ?
- nayefc 13y agoNo Jabber?
- tjosten 13y agoNot sure if troll, but.. XMPP is Jabber.
- inovica 13y agoThis looks nice but what I really still like about Adium is the size of the text entry and the contacts. It can sit unobtrusively at the corner of my screen and I can send/respond to messages without it affecting my work. Personal opinion obviously but one of the reasons I don't like Skype on the Mac now is the size of the text entry
- kbar13 13y agolooks a lot like http://airmailapp.com/ http://airmailapp.com/, is that a standard osx design philosophy or something?
- olssonm 13y agoLooks really awesome – however, as some other people have already said – please make a build for a trial .dmg that you can download directly from your webside (Coda, Versions and other does this) – just so that we can try if it fits into our workflow without puting out $10 up front. The price seems alright, if it works like intended though.
- kozikow 13y agoThe biggest problem I have with Adium is bad facebook chat history support. E.g. if I accidentally talk with someone on android phone or on web site I can't see this in Adium's history. Do you know if Flamingo fixes it?
- joeblau 13y agoThe app looks really clean and very well designed but for $10 I'll need to see a video tutorial or something. I would definitely get on board with this if I could get rid of Messages.
- benjaminwootton 13y agoHas instant messaging declined in popularity from it's heyday of ICQ, AIM, MSN messenger etc? I spent hours chatting on those things, but nowadays seem to get by just fine without. I'm guessing that Facebook Messaging meets the need for most people, but putting IM on the web as a feature within a walled garden is a step backwards for something that was, and still could be, as ubiquitous as email. I think there's still a gap for someone to innovate in real time messaging. It hasn't really moved on in the last decade as a concept, but I have yet to come across any other platform that replicates the immediacy and connectedness that you used to feel on those long ICQ and MSN chats.
- sprobertson 13y agoUbiquitous mobile messaging might be what happened.
- streeter 13y agoI'd really like to see a way to integrate the history for services like Facebook Chat and Google Hangouts when not using the app. With Google Chat, the app could use IMAP to get the chat history for non-Flamingo chats, but with the switch to Hangouts, that method is no longer possible. It seems Takeout is the only way to get the Hangout message history (https://code.google.com/p/google-plus-platform/issues/detail?id=68 https://code.google.com/p/google-plus-platform/issues/detail...). IMO, the lack of true global history is the biggest limitation of a native app for using many IM services.
- dmazin 13y agoNo AIM? Is this a joke?
- icco 13y agoSo, I tried it out. I have two google hangouts accounts, and this just hangs trying to log into them both. I want this to be awesome, but crashing on load makes it completely useless.
- daenney 13y agoIt looks really nice but unfortunately without MUC support it's fairly useless to me. We have a lot of conference rooms / MUC's for projects, teams etc. etc. that I would lose access to.