4 ms·
Indeed. There's nothing wrong with Facebook as an advertising channel, when used effectively and with expectations properly calibrated. There's a lot wrong wit
by jonnathanson 13y ago
Indeed. There's nothing wrong with Facebook as an advertising channel, when used effectively and with expectations properly calibrated.
There's a lot wrong with blindly throwing money at a Facebook "fan page" and an ostensible following, expecting miracles to happen and any of those followers to care. (There's also a problem involved in paying for the fans, then reaching a fraction of them with each update -- but that's the nature of how Facebook works, and that shouldn't have been a mystery to most marketers for quite some time now.)
What we're experiencing right now isn't a "revolution" in advertising, as the article suggests. But then again, it's the marketers' fault for expecting there to have been one in the first place. They bought, traded, and sold the hype. Big brands made relatively blind, multi-million-dollar commitments to Facebook and other social channels before stopping to think about what, exactly, they were hoping to achieve.
What those brands are learning today: there's no such thing as a magic bullet. There's no such thing as a free lunch. There's no such thing as a "revolution" in marketing. Nothing will allow you to grow a fanbase, increase engagement, and sell more products without an ounce of forethought and hard work.
Facebook is a channel, like any other. It can be a very effective channel. But like any channel, it needs to be thought through, analyzed, and used properly. The blind honeymoon is over. The platform's usefulness remains.
- the_watcher 13y ago>> There's a lot wrong with blindly throwing money at a Facebook "fan page" and an ostensible following, expecting miracles to happen and any of those followers to care. This has actually been by far the worst way of making money off of Facebook in my experience - and I do this full time.
- jonnathanson 13y agoAgreed. The whole "fan page" thing can be a total money pit unless a marketer knows exactly what he's trying to get from the investment. Conversely, I've had fantastic results from targeted ad buys on Facebook. In particular, mobile app install buys. Great results, decent tracking, easy to analyze from an ROI and LTV standpoint. Just because you can target people by #anything doesn't mean they'll care about your content. Your content has to fit what you're targeting and whom you're targeting. I feel as though a lot of brand marketers -- ordinarily extremely smart people -- lost their senses about this when they first jumped on the Facebook bandwagon. I've seen some very sophisticated AdWords buyers treat Facebook like a Magic 8 Ball, for instance. It blows my mind.