4 ms·
What we need is strong fundamental protections of "rights", which no representatives can overrule. Direct democracy can be far worse, since when the majority b
by EGreg 13y ago
What we need is strong fundamental protections of "rights", which no representatives can overrule.
Direct democracy can be far worse, since when the majority becomes fickle and wants to kill someone (such as Socrates) who is there to stop them? And worse, it's usually the VOCAL ACTIVIST minority that goes and votes or intimidates others, such as the nazi party.
Thinking direct democracy will solve everything is naive. Here are some links:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice#Special_interests http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice#Special_interests
And by the way getting 25% of people to vote is not easy, without fines being imposed on the non-voters. Facebook wasn't even able to get 3% of people to vote, and that was online clicking a button.
Publius (federalist papers) wrote about democracies that they: have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal security or the rights of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths. (Federalist 10)
The founders of the USA are kind of like the writers of the initial codebase and the protocol for amending it. Before there was programming, there was ... legal constitution writing.
- thangalin 13y agoThe problem with direct democracy is that it does not necessarily encourage deliberation nor the dissemination of factual information (i.e., education). There are other ways of implementing direct democracy without having the system subjected to the whims and follies of special interest groups. https://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/ https://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/ Read the idea, review the mock-ups, and please provide constructive critiques on how the idea can be improved. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6518237 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6518237
- david927 13y agoWe have them. They are constantly overruled. Gitmo, for example, is in direct violation of nearly all of them. If we allow people to vote directly on bills, the constitutionality remains enforced, which means the founders would be happy and Socrates would be safe. The Nazi party was representative, that wasn't direct democracy. You put out a lot of arguments but none of them showed very much thought.
- EGreg 13y agoCalifornia has direct democracy to a great extent. Let's see how well that works out for them in terms of economics for example. The Nazi party is an example of a vocal and violent minority intimidating the majority into voting the "right way" for a single party to take over or staying away from the polls. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_election_and_referendum,_1936 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_election_and_referendum,... is this the kind of thing you want?
- dobbsbob 13y agoNapoleon used direct democracy to make himself dictator its always been a tool of tyrants, and the referendum questions manipulated
- david927 13y agoNonsense. Overthrowing Louis XVI was one of the most important movements of the enlightenment. Napoleon was popularly supported, remember, because people were sick of the monarchy. Democracy, direct or not, is the way forward. Accept it or not.
- dobbsbob 13y ago"Plebiscites are “referenda”, people’s votes, in which an authoritarian ruler invites the people to answer an often ambivalent, suggestive question, which he formulates himself. Using such plebiscites, a ruler bypasses and ignores his elected parliament and tries to claim direct legitimacy from the people. In this he is wrong, because he does not respect or follow parliament which has indeed been elected by the people and expresses their diversity and different interests" In your case this would be bypassing congress, and bypassing debate because referenda are always formulated in questions that cant be debated. You're with us or with the evil doers
- nate_meurer 13y agoNice, thanks for this. For others' ease of navigation, the quote above comes from http://ukrainianweek.com/Columns/50/74762 http://ukrainianweek.com/Columns/50/74762