3 ms·
Go back one item in his posts, to http://delian.io/an-apology-to-president-reif-and-the-mit-community http://delian.io/an-apology-to-president-reif-and-the-mit-
by hga 13y ago
Go back one item in his posts, to http://delian.io/an-apology-to-president-reif-and-the-mit-community http://delian.io/an-apology-to-president-reif-and-the-mit-co...
"..."
I can't imagine trusting this guy, or anyone willing to work with him, with ... anything, let alone implicit and explicit access to medical information, until he presumably grows up a bit a decade or two from now.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat's pretty harsh. It seems like it was a relatively harmless prank that he didn't even intend and immediately regretted. I don't understand why you judge that so harshly or why you immediately dismiss his work based on it.
- hga 13y agoHaving learned more (see the additions to my reply to his reply), I wasn't even vaguely harsh enough. He should have done some jail time (a few weeks, a misdemeanor is enough), and if he reapplies to get back into MIT I hope the Dean he has to talk to doesn't go softhearted absent a major attitude adjustment that has yet to occur a solid half year later. Of course, I'm also one of those members of the MIT community who believe Aaron Swartz should have done some serious time in Club Fed (> a year, i.e. felony), am not in the least swayed by his exit from a mess entirely of his own making ("If you aren't willing to do the time, don't do the crime.", incalculably stupid for someone who suffered from depression), and am rather perturbed by all those taking the side of a criminal again MIT to the point of committing even more crimes against the community, like this one. To answer the rest of your points, it comes down to character, and his actions and most especially his responses afterwords conclusively demonstrate he isn't worthy of the trust which is required for this sort of access to people's health information. I don't "dismiss his work" so much as "don't trust him or anyone of such poor judgement to work with him" with a service handling sensitive stuff.
- MIT_Hacker 13y agoAhhh. The past always burns. You live and you learn.
- hga 13y agoYou know, some of us never had to learn from that sort of experience not to do seriously damaging things, especially when the potential for damage is so obviously high, and the activity is entirely optional. People like you give "hackers" and at least the newer generations of MIT undergraduates a bad name. ADDED: Your fellow members of the MIT community aren't too impressed with all this including your apology: http://tech.mit.edu/V133/N13/fakeemail.html?comments#comments http://tech.mit.edu/V133/N13/fakeemail.html?comments#comment... AND MORE ADDED: And now reading them, you did this during "hell week" (midterms)? Were you even still a student then??? FINAL ADDITION: can you show us the slightest evidence you've learned anything but "Don't get caught next time" (assuming the speculation that this was more a PR stunt than anything else per some of the comments in The Tech is false)? Disclosures: I'm class of 1983 and have close non-academic ties to Course 6.