6 ms·
"The messages will disparage other gangs in a backhanded way. In a Blood letter, you’ll see that the letter C is usually crossed out or has a slash through it o
by smcl 13y ago
"The messages will disparage other gangs in a backhanded way. In a Blood letter, you’ll see that the letter C is usually crossed out or has a slash through it out of disrespect for the Crips. And to praise themselves, they’ll write a B with an up arrow."
It's so strange that there's these very serious gangs responsible for traumatising large areas in US cities, yet they do massively petty things like writing a "WE R KOOL" up-arrow beside a 'B' in their correspondence, and crossing out a 'C' (if they're a Blood that is). I can't connect that juvenile elementary school behaviour with gang violence and shootings, it seems so contradictory.
- INTPenis 13y agoMaybe because many of them dropped out of elementary school due to poverty and gangs.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoGang violence is the default state; it is the behavior that children will naturally develop without being socialized (and return to, whether child or adult, in the absence of authority). You're observing that these gang members haven't been socialized out of instinctive self-congratulation in their writing, or out of instinctive pack behavior. I don't see the disconnect.
- sneak 13y ago> (and return to, whether child or adult, in the absence of authority) [citation needed]
- narag 13y agoI haven't any. But Lord of the Flies is nice as food for thought. Also there's a film based on the book.
- bediger4000 13y agoFiction, both of them. So no references for violence as a default state of society so far, just aphorisms and "common knowledge".
- robotresearcher 13y agoA very influential reference that proposes this idea: "Leviathan", Thomas Hobbes, England, 1651. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(book) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(book) From the Wikipedia summary: "[The] natural state of man is not to be found in a political community that pursues the greatest good. But to be outside of a political community is to be in an anarchic condition. Given human nature, the variability of human desires, and need for scarce resources to fulfill those desires, the state of nature, as Hobbes calls this anarchic condition, must be a war of all against all. Even when two men are not fighting, there is no guarantee that the other will not try to kill him for his property or just out of an aggrieved sense of honour, and so they must constantly be on guard against one another. It is even reasonable to preemptively attack one's neighbour." The truth of Hobbes' "State of Nature" is still debated, for example in this thread, almost 500 years later. It's a well known idea in philosophy and politics.
- keevie 13y agoHobbes is hugely influential, but the 'truth' of the Hobbesian state of nature isn't debated at all. Political philosophy doesn't take seriously claims about "human nature" like that. Source: studying political theory in college; read leviathan twice.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- shin_lao 13y agoEnough with the "citation needed". This isn't Wikipedia. People have the right to express an opinion or don't have reference for everything they say. How would you react if someone told you "citation needed" every time you make a claim?
- colanderman 13y agoI would learn to write "I think that" in front of things that are my opinions.
- scott_s 13y agoThis sub-thread follows the same pattern as one I participated in over a year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4272117 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4272117
- bronbron 13y agoThat sounds repetitive and kind of annoying to read. It's usually obvious from context what's opinion and what's not, and you can always ask for clarification in those rarer instances. For example, it's pretty obvious the OP is stating opinion. You don't need to couch your opinions with "I think" or "It's my opinion that". Have some conviction.
- dspillett 13y ago> Obvious to you. And me for that matter. Obvious to you, and me for that matter, but obviously not obvious to everyone or this sub-thread would not exist. Every one in this threat seems to be well enough versed on English that a specific language barrier isn't an issue, but there are probably people for whom English is a third or forth language: the chance of them seeing as obvious everything that we pick out as obvious is going to be lower than for those with more practise at the language. > Have some conviction. It is not about conviction, it is about accurately displaying the source and potential veracity of the information being presented. I couch my opinions so it doesn't look like I'm stating a commonly known fact instead of something I've supposed. Of course where I'm pretty damn sure what I'm stating is verifiable fact I'll not bother adding the extra words, but if you always assume you are correct and write in a style that suggests such, then you may be one of those people! Adding a few extra words to tell the reader this extra information about the (potential) quality of the information you are about to impart is useful IMO. Be as fine grained as you like too: somewhere between "I think that" and "I know" is "It is my understanding that..." and so on.
- aurelius 13y agoYou sound like a Christian fundamentalist. Are you looking for a Biblical citation?
- calibraxis 13y agoYes, it's not incomprehensible. There's other structures like gangs. Nation-states, also capitalist firms if they sell drugs/prostitution. Not hard to see (at least by analogy) why they're inherently violent, top-down institutions. Also, "juvenile elementary school behaviour" is something I observe all the time among programmers. At one office, I've heard people simply saying "penis" and of course jokes about mothers. It's what people do in absurd workplaces, where they're not working towards higher purposes beyond selling some crap product and making money.
- TeMPOraL 13y ago"Juvenile elementary school behaviour", when related to nation states, is usually called "patriotism". Also, sports fans tend to exhibit similar behaviour wrt. to their favourite teams.
- nicholassmith 13y agoA quick Google suggests the average age of a gang member is 16-24yrs, which probably has an impact on why it seems so juvenile.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoReally? You see no connection between poor impulse control/low intelligence and pointless violence? The research in fact shows the former to be the only significant predictor of the latter. (Parent socioeconomic status, culture, and education have very little additional predictive power once impulsivity/intelligence are taken into account.) I also take issue with gangs being "responsible" for traumatising cities. In U.S. cities, it is common for a successful district to share a border with a gangland district. Usually the crime abruptly decreases at the border of the successful district. The difference is not gang member presence—no repulsor field keeps them from walking across the street. The difference is that the police in the gangland district are not allowed to stop them because that would be "racist".
- smcl 13y agoI associate this sort of writing with little girls dotting their 'i's with love hearts and therefore childhood innocence and struggle to connect that with gang violence. In re "responsible" I think you're interpreting what I said a little strangely. Gangs are behind serious adult crimes, and as I said I just find it weird that these serious crimes are caused by people decorating their letters like little kids. Nobody is blaming all society's ills on gangs.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoGangland is a lot like a school for 12 year olds. A group of insecure, unconfident people are brought together as a matter of policy. They are rewarded for doing things together as a matter of policy (drug money, media adulation). Attempts at self-policing are shut down by the authorities. Is it that surprising that the cultures are so similar?
- johndavidback 13y agoIf you read the last paragraph in the OP, you'll notice that officer has "appreciation" for their intelligence. It's very short-sighted to assume that they are of low intelligence or have poor impulse control. Being born into poverty provides a very limited means of social mobility, so joining a gang is often a rational, and intelligent, decision.
- betterunix 13y agoIt is just a way to encourage loyalty to the gang. Gangs would fall apart without rituals like this.
- jessaustin 13y agoYay Drug War! Enabling permanent childhood for the violent, uneducated, and unsocialized at the expense of everyone else! What a great idea!