5 ms·
They would likely be millions of years ahead of us. It's very unlikely two intelligent species would happen to evolve within a few thousand years of each other.
by Houshalter 13y ago
They would likely be millions of years ahead of us. It's very unlikely two intelligent species would happen to evolve within a few thousand years of each other. So either natural evolution, or more likely self-modification, would have had tons of time to improve. Not to mention artificial intelligence.
They could be millions or billions of times more intelligent than us. And imagine a mind the size of the Earth, or the size of Jupiter, with the energy of their entire star.
- mtdewcmu 13y agoThere's reason to think that we're maxed out on intelligence. Our heads are about as big as could fit through the birth canal. A brain as big as a planet couldn't possibly work, and if it had the energy of a star, it would be made of plasma at millions of degrees Kelvin.
- Houshalter 13y agoWe are actually only on the cusp of intelligence. The very first things to emerge from evolution capable of building a technological civilization. If it were possible for chimpanzee brains to build a technological civilization, we would be having this conversation at an even lower level of intelligence. The brain was designed by evolution, a very stupid and slow process. We are the result of iteratively improving what worked good at controlling locomotion in fish. Certainly we can make improvements, certainly we can do better. The fact that the human brain is limited to fitting through the birth canal is a great example. With c-sections that isn't particularly relevant, and computers/AI aren't limited in size or energy requirements at all (or at least not anywhere near the same constraints that humans have.) So imagine if brains that constraint was removed and you made brains dozens, hundreds, or even millions of times larger. You could build a computer the size of a planet, though it would require a ridiculous amount of technological ability. The energy of a star doesn't mean literally as hot as a star, but something like thousands of solar panels to efficiently collect as much of the energy as possible for powering the enormous computer. It was just an example of what the limits of technology might be.
- mtdewcmu 13y ago> The fact that the human brain is limited to fitting through the birth canal is a great example. With c-sections that isn't particularly relevant A bright future for mankind, but less great for womankind. We may need to figure out how to use elephants as surrogate mothers.
- Houshalter 13y agoOr test tube babies, or completely artificial brains.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoOr, if we get really good at bioengineering, we could figure out how to fit more brainpower into less space, and thus allow the skull to shrink a little bit.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoA) Our cognitive structure is not actually that stupid. Note that many-layered neural networks are at the forefront of modern Machine Learning, a discipline carried out by educated, technology-using sapients who will immediately switch to some better technique the instant they find one. Indeed, there is active research into better learning techniques. Neural networks may not be the peak, but they're Pretty Good enough that they didn't evolve "by mistake" in nature. B) We are still evolving. The big overwhelming FACT of civilization didn't halt our evolution, it just changed the nature of the selection pressures. Whereas raw, physical survivability was once the prime selection factor, civilization has made reproductive desirability, social cooperation, and parenting ability (all inter-related but nonidentical) the larger selection pressures on human genomes. C) The big new adaptation that made us humans what we are was only maybe intelligence. It was probably extelligence: the ability to store knowledge in the social group rather than the individual. That way, you can build your collective knowledge over time. D) You would have to be a stupidly, suicidally cancerous civilization to go around converting whole planets into tools.
- Houshalter 13y ago