2 ms·
"I definitely agree that students should have a good foundation for how to use technology as a tool in their lives, but going as far to say that students should
by dllthomas 13y ago
"I definitely agree that students should have a good foundation for how to use technology as a tool in their lives, but going as far to say that students should be able to program the tools they use is a stretch. Do we emphasize writing skills to the extent that every student should become the next best-seller?"
Should we expect every student to be able to build a full-fledged (say) statistical modeling package? No, of course not. Should we expect students to know their way around "programming" well enough to express what they want to do in the domain they choose to work in without clicking through menus? Absolutely. To compare the latter to "writing a best-selling novel" would be inane. We should teach kids to write well enough that they can write a moderate length letter, and we should teach kids to program well enough that they can write a moderate length script.
The notion that the kind of programming instruction we give to anyone pre-college (outside of exceedingly rare circumstances) is more like the former than the latter is, I think, entirely off base - generally, we don't even give the latter.