4 ms·
I've read that, but thanks for sharing.
by mindcrime 13y ago
I've read that, but thanks for sharing.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't understand how you can read that and then state that the standard for sourcing on WP is "the New York Times". The links I provided contradict your claim.
- mindcrime 13y agothen state that the standard for sourcing on WP is "the New York Times" I didn't state that the NTY is the standard. I am talking about the arguments usually offered up by the deletionists in the afd discussions, where they typically try to insist (and usually somewhat successfully) that a source needs to have the gravitas of the NTY, WaPo, etc., to be accepted. Yeah, it's bullshit, and I wish all those guys would read the above links, but it doesn't seem to happen. So, you have the written de jure standard, as documented, and then you have the actual de facto standard which - often times - is quite different. It doesn't help that the reliable sources guidelines hint at a bias towards "news sources" as a preferred source, in saying: "News reporting" from well-established news outlets is generally considered to be reliable for statements of fact
- tptacek 13y agoThe problem goes both ways, because the proponents of bogus arguments use superficial blog posts and even press releases as sources for their stories. Either way: it is clear on the 2013 Wikipedia that the bar for "reliable source" isn't "major newspaper citation". Something people don't like to acknowledge in these arguments is that for every "Nimrod (Programming Language)" whose inclusion into WP would be harmless or even beneficial, there are 100 bullshit spam company promotion pages lawyering the rules of the site to keep their site bolted to the top of Google for some term they invented. The news media is easy to cite, easier than many other sources, because the fundamental thing Wikipedia is looking for in a reliable source is a notion of editorial responsibility, and the news media is the world's canonical reference for "written accounts with editorial responsibility". But there are others as well.
- jimktrains2 13y agoPlease tell me where the "written accounts with editorial responsibility" are for http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_(programming_language) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_(programming_language) (I only see one that fits your criteria from InformationWeek, does that one reference mean the rest of the page should be deleted? and just one or two sentences kept?). And before you say OSE, should Go not be in Wikipedia? Perhaps we simply have very different and incompatible goals of what we want Wikipedia to be. Also, Wikipedia already puts rel=nofollow in its links. Also, why would someone want their site to appear at the top of Google for a term noöne uses? If they really push and advertise the term enough to make that worth-while, then it'll get talked about in other venues as well.
- tptacek 13y agoThe article makes a direct assertion of notability: it's the product of Ken Thompson and Rob Pike (both already notable), and is in use in production systems at Google. It backs both claims up with reliable sources. And then, yes, it also includes stories from TechCrunch and Information Week, in addition to the TIOBE Language of the Year thing. It's funny you brought it up, because Golang was nominated for AfD (go look at the Talk page), and even more sources were found; they just apparently weren't relevant to the article. On the other hand: nobody seems to be able to find any sources for Nimrod.
- mindcrime 13y agoSomething people don't like to acknowledge in these arguments is that for every "Nimrod (Programming Language)" whose inclusion into WP would be harmless or even beneficial, there are 100 bullshit spam company promotion pages lawyering the rules of the site to keep their site bolted to the top of Google for some term they invented. That's a legitimate concern and I don't claim to have all the answers for all the problems that face Wikipedia. But I remain convinced that "context matters" and that, in context, Nimrod is notable enough that it should be in Wikipedia. Finding a way to reflect that distinction to the satisfaction of all parties involved is an open problem, granted.
- ErrantX 13y agoThat's really not true though, at least from my experience! In the AFD that is exampled here, the only sources offered were of the form of blogs and forum posts etc. Wikipedia has quite clear and explicit rules against those sorts of sources (for establishing notability) for very well explained reasons. I've always been a bit rolly-eyes at situations like this... Niche wikis are easy to start and can be well-maintained. I bet a programming wiki would be well serviced with a bit of effort. Wikipedia is a general purpose encyclopaedia that has rules designed to cover lots of content, but in such a way as to try and ensure it is as accurate and non-fancrufty as possible. Sometimes notable topics get pushed out on technicalities, sometimes fancruft sneaks in. It's an imperfect system, but in general there is a lot of information there. Unfortunately there is a perception that Wikipedia is the place to be; and individuals with no investment other than to mention (I'm avoiding the word promote because of the connotations) their favourite topic pop their content in expecting it to be fine. It's a little like the old forum ettiquette of the 90's - you didn't hope into a forum and start posting about your new programming language without first checking the forum rules to see if it was okay. The Wikimedia Community is also a great curator for niche Wikis (see Wikinews, Wikiversity, Wikiquote, Wiktionary et al.). They recently took on a couple of travel wiki communities. The programming community is dedicated, large, and relatively well educated - there is no reason a Programming Wiki wouldn't work. It would, however, take time and effort for a group to bootstrap - and unfortunately Wikipedia is not the way to sidestep that leg work. (speaking as a long term editor with several featured articles; so hence biased!)
- jimktrains2 13y agoSo your solution is to fork Wikipedia into smaller and smaller pieces? These seems like a bad idea. Also, I don't know who created the original page, but how do you know it wasn't someone not on the core dev team? Perhaps everyone involved _did_ follow the rules, but interpreted "notability" differently. Also, don't go all appeal to authority on us. I've been an editor for over 7 years now.
- mindcrime 13y agoThat's really not true though, at least from my experience! All I can say is that my experience clearly differs from yours then. But I tend to get involved in the controversial afd discussions a lot, for some reason. In the AFD that is exampled here, the only sources offered were of the form of blogs and forum posts etc. Wikipedia has quite clear and explicit rules against those sorts of sources (for establishing notability) for very well explained reasons. Again, "context matters". We need to find a way to incorporate that point. We can't just wave our hands, dismiss all blog posts and primary sources, and reject everything on those grounds. For a programming language (not just nimrod, but many languages) you just aren't going to get a lot of other sources. But, in context, they are notable and the sources are credible. I'm not claiming to have a final answer to all of this, but I sense that we can do better.