2 ms·
Again, Tucker made his argument from first principles, in a non-hindsight fashion (he was writing when Lenin was a teen). So it would be hard to argue that it'
by dnautics 13y ago
Again, Tucker made his argument from first principles, in a non-hindsight fashion (he was writing when Lenin was a teen). So it would be hard to argue that it's not inevitable, because it was empirically shown and in a prior fashion mechanistically predicted (this is the minimum bar for creating a law in the physical sciences), unless you can point out exactly what needs to happen differently from how Tucker envisioned it.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Again, Tucker made his argument from first principles, in a non-hindsight fashion (he was writing when Lenin was a teen). So it would be hard to argue that it's not inevitable The conclusion does not follow from the premise. That an argument was made "from first principles" doesn't make it hard to argue against. > because it was empirically shown I would disagree with the claim that what Tucker actually predicted was empirically shown, but this whole discussion is widely afield from the point.