3 ms·
Things aren't over-engineered, they're poorly engineered. It's supposed to be the art of taking away until nothing unnecessary left. The common practice is to
by colechristensen 13y ago
Things aren't over-engineered, they're poorly engineered. It's supposed to be the art of taking away until nothing unnecessary left. The common practice is to replace things which are difficult to engineer or expensive to manufacture with electronics and _that_ is the failure.
- sp332 13y agoThe Nest isn't that kind of engineering. It took a programmable thermostat (already overkill for most people's use cases) and added even more automation on top.
- duncan_bayne 13y agoDo you know how much money you can save with a programmable thermostat? We took a good 25% off our gas central-heating bill by having one fitted.
- cantankerous 13y agoHis point isn't that a programmable thermostat isn't worthwhile, but that most people don't want it even if they should. Moreover, the OP notes that the Nest is overkill as far as programmable thermostats go.
- derleth 13y ago> It's supposed to be the art of taking away until nothing unnecessary left. Except if I can't understand your use case, none of the complexity related to it is needed, so it's all excess and must be removed. After all, we have a Model T, so why do we need a Ford Focus? They both move you along under engine power. In other words, a lot of engineers seem to have a Procrustean Bed and a deep need to cut problems down to size in the name of cutting solutions down to size. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procrustes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procrustes
- hvidgaard 13y agoYou're taking it too literally. Since Model T, cars have improved tremendously. Efficiency, comfort, and safety are still getting better year after year. That is engineering with a goal, to make a better vehicle. Things like hydraulic power steering is a good thing. It is there for a reason, and taking it away does not make better engineering. It is however being replaced with electronic power steering, for the exact engineering reasons. Before we could make reasonable good electronic power steering, there was nothing to take away from the hydraulic steering, but taking away the power steering itself, would be a step back.