4 ms·
Why does "partially-sighted people are likely to have lower quality of life than fully-sighted ones" feel wrong to you? In the extreme cases (say, Tay-Sachs dis
by PeterisP 13y ago
Why does "partially-sighted people are likely to have lower quality of life than fully-sighted ones" feel wrong to you? In the extreme cases (say, Tay-Sachs disease) it is clear that some people will definitely have a lower quality of life than others, so in general there is a difference, and it's only a question for which problems the genetic quality-of-life differences are insignificantly small compared to other factors.
But sight (IMHO) is a very important thing.
Think of it this way - to compare apples with apples, let's talk about a single person, not two people who can be wildly different. The moral dilemmas have different answers for different people, so think from your personal perspective:
If you would/could make some currently fully-sighted person become partially-sighted, would it be a neutral thing or an evil thing, according to your beliefs? Would you have a duty to avoid doing that?
If you would/could make some currently partially-sighted person become fully-sighted, would it be a neutral thing or a good thing, according to your beliefs? Would you have a duty to do that?
If you had an ability to choose between some person being partially- or fully-sighted; or flip a coin instead (50% chance of only partial sight) - would you avoid making the choice? Is it ethical to avoid making the choice?
- blowski 13y ago> Why does "partially-sighted people are likely to have lower quality of life than fully-sighted ones" feel wrong to you? Usain Bolt obviously has two pretty amazing legs, and my legs by contrast must look 'less able'. But I'd be offended if you assumed that Usain Bolt has a better quality of life simply because he has 'more able' legs. So with this gene selection we end up in selecting only those with the legs of Usain Bolt. I feel the same about sight. I'm fairly short-sighted so wear glasses, and my glasses are kind of part of my personality. Even if somebody wanted to pay for the laser surgery, and it was a guaranteed success, I can't say that I'd definitely do it. So in the case of your questions - if somebody asked me to improve their sight, and it was in my power to do so, then I would do it. But I don't think it would guarantee them a better quality of life.