3 ms·
I'm actually reading your examples as arguments for doing it - if the decision point is "should I do this for my next kid", then: Class: No matter what class I
by PeterisP 13y ago
I'm actually reading your examples as arguments for doing it - if the decision point is "should I do this for my next kid", then:
Class: No matter what class I am, I would definitely want my kids to [have a chance of] go a class higher than I am, and if I would deny my kids that opportunity for my own reasons, then that would be an evil, selfish act against my children;
Cruelty: If such society really is likely, then the same argument applies even more; I have a clear duty to protect my kids from such cruelty, and that duty is more important than the need to protect myself from some discrimination or conserve financial resources;
Race: well, it doesn't apply for me (same race marriage, all embryos would be the same), so I can't honestly say how it'd feel - but yes, given current experience in many countries it will mean that there will be a bias of skin color. But does it have horrible consequences? I mean, the current effect of gender-biased abortions in large Asian countries results in skewed gender rates and the excess males w/o mates will create social unrest; but race IMHO is generally a cosmetic difference, so nothing really changes if suddenly all of Earth decides to have white, black or purple skin.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoAnd that is exactly why this will become a runaway success/runaway societal problem. Because no sane parent would opt-out and put their own child at risk.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoRace is far more than cosmetic; but lets address that part. If many parents choose to blunt the racial characteristics (not just skin color but eyes/lids, nose width, lips, limb length, jaw, teeth) it will serve to make any 'normal' child with those characteristics a real standout. Racial characteristics become almost proof of genetic inferiority. There's no problem with that?
- PeterisP 13y agoCalling it cosmetic was a gross oversimplification, sorry. Race may be a very differenting feature, but all the research on it is very controversial. That being said, what I mean is that there are only two options - if some racially related features are objectively superior, then we as a species actually should select towards those features; and if all racial features are equal in 'goodness', and then it is purely cosmetic and it doesn't matter which option people choose. As for the second statement - Any 'improvements' that are sufficiently large to matter will probably be sufficiently large to detect; the problem is about how we treat "genetic inferiority" as such, not really about how it is detected - by looking at racial characteristics, blood samples, asking your parents or your next-gen-facebook-DNA-profile. I feel that your points sum up, in essence, to 'this will lead to more inequality'. And yes, it will. Probably the only thing that can make it equal is to ensure that everybody can do that (although we can't ensure even that everybody can eat or not be a slave) - since we definitely can't ensure that nobody will do that.