3 ms·
If you have a hereditary genetic disease risk that you need/want (depending on the disease) to screen against, then the process is about as follows: 1. Make up
by PeterisP 13y ago
If you have a hereditary genetic disease risk that you need/want (depending on the disease) to screen against, then the process is about as follows:
1. Make up a few (say, 6) in-vitro fertilized eggs;
2. Extract a cell (or multiple cells at later stage, depends on the tech) to run the genetic tests;
3. Discard those who carry the mutation;
4. Depending on random factors, now you have 0-4 potential embryos. If you have many, you need to choose which one(s) will be put in the mother.
And this is the interesting part. At that point you already know quite a lot about each of those genomes - at the very least you definitely know all of their genders, but you do know (or can easily know) much much more already with the current tech. You have to make a choice anyway from that 'menu' of the few genomes that were just created. And absolutely any choice other than complete randomness will be biased towards something. So, the question to society, what amount of choice is 'acceptable'? Is throwing dice ok? Is looking at simulated extrapolated portraits ok? Is looking at statistical data allowed before making the choice?
- blowski 13y agoI think part of the reason I'm uncomfortable with this is that those characteristics I would most desire for my chlid, are not selectable. For example, happiness, gratitude, tolerance, etc. It's not clear whether greater intelligence makes you more or less happy.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoIs choosing a boy to carry on the family name ok? (never mind there are no/few girls to marry any more)