4 ms·
> Returning CO2 levels to historic lows, or blocking solar radiation, might not be able to return the system to its original state: these reactions may not be r
by anamax 17y ago
> Returning CO2 levels to historic lows, or blocking solar radiation, might not be able to return the system to its original state: these reactions may not be reversible.
I thought that it was generally agreed that CO2 levels had been much higher in prehistoric times. If so, it's unclear why recovering from lower levels in the future would be irreversible when we got here from there before.
- encoderer 17y agoAs I understand it, the oldest record we have of past CO2 levels is glacial ice cores that go back about 600k years. In those, at least, CO2 has never been higher than today.
- jibiki 17y agoIt is hypothesized that Earth's atmosphere initially contained much higher % C02. "Based on today's volcanic evidence, this atmosphere would have contained 80% water vapor, 10% carbon dioxide, 5 to 7% hydrogen-sulfur, and smaller amounts of nitrogen, carbon monoxide, hydrogen, methane and inert gases." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_atmosphere#Earliest_atmosphere http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_atmosphere#Earliest_a...
- CWuestefeld 17y agoWell, surely the CO2 level itself could be reversed. But what other elements of the system's equilibrium will be changed in the meantime. For example, the actual amount of temperature increase observed is less than the CO2 level increase would suggest. Suppose that whatever agency has tempered the temperature increase has "woken up", and continues to do so as CO2 decreases. Then a return to "proper" CO2 levels (if you can call any level proper) would mean serious global cooling. And this might not be evident until it's too late. Of course, I'm making that up, but there's no reason to think that it's implausible.
- anamax 17y ago> Suppose that whatever agency has tempered the temperature increase has "woken up", and continues to do so as CO2 decreases. Why is that a reasonable thing to suppose? We're assuming that we got to here from there before. Why is it reasonable to assume that we can't do so again? Yes, maybe something else has changed, but shouldn't you at least go to the trouble of identifying actual possibilities instead of just assuming that they exist?
- CWuestefeld 17y agoThere are any number of processes that will occur easily in one direction, but can have... dramatic... results in the other direction. Consider, by analogy, breaking H2O into hydrogen and oxygen, vs. recombining them. Or, for more fun, consider a girl wearing a skirt, jumping on a trampoline. The process of going up is ordinary, but what happens on the way down is quite a bit different. It's easy to dream up scenarios in the environment that might work this way. Algal blooms that have been pushed along by increased CO2 will affect the equilibrium between other types of sea life -- plankton up the line through large predatory fish. Moving up the food chain, creatures use input food less efficiently (carnivores need to kill much more food by mass than bunnies). So the algae enables plankton, which in turn feeds mackerel which in turn enable more sharks, but turning it around, as the algae recedes, the mackerel are pressured by the already-larger shark population, so they may well be decimated by the CO2 decrease. (I don't know if this specific example is correct -- it’s certainly oversimplified -- but the concept is certainly conceivable). Reiterating: it’s very complex, we don’t really know.
- anamax 17y ago> There are any number of processes that will occur easily in one direction, but can have... dramatic... results in the other direction. Consider, by analogy, breaking H2O into hydrogen and oxygen, vs. recombining them. Ooh, dramatic. Except that the issue is irreversible. You can split and combine hydrogen and oxygen repeatedly and the same thing happens every time. We don't see evidence of dramatic effects from the last time CO2 levels were high and went down. (We also don't see evidence of the predicte runaway temperatures either, but I digress.) If you're going to argue that this time will be different, shouldn't you have something better than "we don't know"? Yes, we might see species changes. However, niches don't stay empty. And, the claim was "irreversible temperature changes".