7 ms·
There is a thing in most kinds of investing and trading called slippage. This is when you decide you want to buy something at say $100/unit but by the time your
by gaius 13y ago
There is a thing in most kinds of investing and trading called slippage. This is when you decide you want to buy something at say $100/unit but by the time your order reaches the market, the price has moved, maybe it's $101, maybe it's $99. If you are buying a lot, then it's unlikely there's a single counterparty you can trade with, so you will actually be doing it as many smaller trades. Sometimes slippage moves for you, sometimes against but that's not the kind of trading you want to do because it involves taking on more risk, you want confidence that the price you ask for is the price you're going to get, and you don't want your trades to affect the price. HFT techniques are invaluable here.
- ksk 13y agoIf you want to adopt a pro-HFT position, can you point to a single major market volatility event when the insanely risk-averse HFT algorithms, didn't just shutdown? I've looked, I haven't found any. Would be nice if they did exist as it would invalidate some of the HFT criticism.
- gaius 13y agoWe're not talking about major events, we're just talking about everyday normal trading. My entire point is that HFT is valuable for reducing risk for this kind of work, you say "risk-averse" like it's a bad thing... It's not a case, btw, of being pro- or anti-. HFT is just a tool. You can use any tool in any way, it doesn't care because it has no moral agency of its own.
- ksk 13y ago>My entire point is that HFT is valuable for reducing risk for this kind of work, you say "risk-averse" like it's a bad thing... Er.. One of the fundamental reasons that HFT exists is increased market liquidity. Re-read what you wrote. You imply HFTs reduce risk and at the same time seem to accept that they are risk-averse - ergo unable to reduce risk as they shutdown when the markets risk profile increases. So which is it? Oh and btw, since no humans trade securities at such a high frequency, The HFT trading that takes up such a sizeable portion of the total pie, is just an electronic game being played between two competing firms. So, even if they did reduce risk, it would not help human participants.
- gaius 13y agoYou are conflating market risk with counterparty/exchange risk there. Wikipaedia is your friend...
- ksk 13y agoOK, we're arguing two different things. My one and only point is HFTs shut-shop at the slightest sign of risk, leaving you to trade at massive losses - precisely because there are no HFT like counterparties ready to buy/sell inventory. IIUC Your position seems to be that HFTs amongst themselves can allow for an order execution strategy of breaking up the order into chunks to discount for the price change that occurs when you increase supply of a security while selling it. If that is your position then I withdraw my protest because I agree with it.
- wglb 13y agoThe flash crash was one major one. Some of the HFT firms bailed out, some (the market makers) were required by their contracts with the exchanges to stay in. One reference: http://www.advfn.com/nasdaq/StockNews.asp?stocknews=CME&article=42714334 http://www.advfn.com/nasdaq/StockNews.asp?stocknews=CME&arti... I've looked, Where did you look? That is kind of a big one to miss.
- ksk 13y agoHey, thanks for supporting my point.
- anologwintermut 13y agoAs would trading on a clock. If the market only updated once a second or even a far smaller interval, this whole insane business would be mostly irrelevant.
- gaius 13y ago... And then people would worry about being exactly on the second, not a millisecond over.
- anologwintermut 13y agoIf there's not difference between the start of an interval and the end, it doesn't matter much. A second is a long enough time to get an order in that at least people won't be doing insane things to reduce latency.
- easytiger 13y agoThen proximity to the second tick would be the game. What you are advocating would have people sending orders in the future to arrive at the gateway as timer expires.
- anologwintermut 13y agoPerhaps I'm missing something, but why would it matter? Trades execute at the state in t-1 at time t. Assuming people's orders are secret in that interval, you don't actually care when your trade gets queued.