4 ms·
Not to mention the bubble-startup business model, raise a billion from VCs and blow it. That money belongs to pension funds, university endowments, charity trus
by gaius 13y ago
Not to mention the bubble-startup business model, raise a billion from VCs and blow it. That money belongs to pension funds, university endowments, charity trusts...
- pron 13y agoIt's not a zero-sum game like trading, though. You do try to benefit society and the economy, and even if you don't succeed, people make a living off that "blown" money.
- mseebach 13y agoa) Trading isn't zero-sum. If you meant to say HFT, no, that isn't zero-sum either. b) Trying isn't enough. A billion blown is a billion blown, it doesn't matter what your intentions are - and if it does, I'm sure most HFT-traders are convinced that they are benefiting society and the economy. c) People are also making a living of off money spend in HFT-space, regardless of what their intentions are.
- CmonDev 13y agoThe only thing business with shareholders wants is maximizing the profits. Besides, how are you going to IPO your start-up without traders involved? Capitalism without trading sounds like communism without common property.
- pron 13y agoA stock exchange doesn't need traders. We all buy and sell things all the time without the help of traders. Retailers and importers provide, in their domain, a much more valuable service than traders do in theirs. We don't even need traders for traditional risk-reducing options trading for farmers and manufacturers. > The only thing business with shareholders wants is maximizing the profits. In the US, generally yes. In other countries (like Germany), businesses have other goals, like providing sustenance to workers.
- CmonDev 13y ago"like providing sustenance to workers." when enforced by government that is, in some countries you don't even have to pay tax.
- pron 13y agoThat government is elected by the people. It's not a foreign occupier. So I guess that the people of Germany have chosen to make businesses not just about maximizing profit.
- gaius 13y agoIt's not clear to me how society benefits from ever more intrusive ways to show people ads, and "people make a living" in that context is the same as Reagan's so-called "trickle down economics".