4 ms·
Motivation is an issue - each verification would require a bunch man-months of effort, so it won't happen unless there is separate funding for that or somehow m
by PeterisP 13y ago
Motivation is an issue - each verification would require a bunch man-months of effort, so it won't happen unless there is separate funding for that or somehow magically started to be as prestigious as putting the same effort in a new experiment/publication.
"Requiring" has the same motivation problem - those who could require it, currently would rather require those students to do something that brings funding or prestige, so they won't.
- tensor 13y agoGraduate students are already required to take courses and various tests that don't bring funding or prestige. This could simply be an additional requirement, or replace an existing requirement. In time, such a program would bring quite a lot of prestige as flaws are discovered and fixed in existing work. It's really the easiest and most immediate way to address this problem since it only needs to involve single institutions (whose faculty presumably care deeply about this issue). It doesn't seem likely that journals will suddenly start valuing verification work. Similarly, politicians and funding agencies appear uninterested in actual science; they care only about their careers or immediate application to the politically popular cause of the day.
- XorNot 13y agoGraduate students already verify people's work. Because every new graduate project involves building on the work of previous science. Which by definition involves re-verifying the work to show you get the same results. If the results are hard to replicate, or dependent on other causes, then usually that's when a project shifts or when the knowledge pool expands (for example chemistry is fraught with environmental effect dangers - fluorescent lights provide UV to reactions, your glassware has imperfections, the temperature and humidity of labs varies with climate).
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoI would say that falsifying an existing publication should easily be at least as prestigious and funding-worthy as having made that publication in the first place.