5 ms·
Why is raising the gas tax not an option? I mean, almost noone wants to pay more taxes, but if the road fund needs to take money then it's far simpler to raise
by PeterisP 13y ago
Why is raising the gas tax not an option? I mean, almost noone wants to pay more taxes, but if the road fund needs to take money then it's far simpler to raise the existing tax rate rather than implement a new process, collection agency, and monitoring tools.
The rate listed in article (18 cents/gallon) is not a big influence to prevent driving - it's ten times less than the gas excise tax I pay in EU, which comes out to a bit less than $2 per US gallon. Business doesn't stop because of it, and there's extra motivation to reduce the polluting transportation.
- Zak 13y agoLast time I checked the figures, at a Federal level at least, fuel taxes did cover the costs of maintaining the highway system. If the highway system needs more maintenance, increasing the fuel tax by a relatively small amount would likely cover it. I'm generally not one to argue in favor of taxation, but fuel taxes are essentially user fees for the road system. Unless and until most cars use something as an energy source that's hard to tax in this way, it's a viable, and mostly fair way to pay for roads. There's even a significant correlation between a vehicle's fuel economy and how much damage it does to the road, as both are closely related to weight.
- walshemj 13y agoYou realize the hypothecation is a bad thing and has some serious downsides
- Zak 13y agoYou realize the hypothecation is a bad thing No, I don't. That strikes me as an opinion that's honestly debatable and strongly influenced by one's value system, especially with regard to what roles a government should and should not play in a society rather than an objective fact. That said, I wasn't necessarily arguing that fuel taxes should only be used to pay for roads nor that roads should only be paid for using fuel taxes. Several people quoted in the article do make claims that are more or less equivalent to "driving should be taxed enough to pay for the roads" then go on to claim that mileage-based rather than fuel-based taxes are a better way to do so. I'm saying that claim is dubious.
- walshemj 13y agoWell the argument goes why as a single person should my taxes go to support your kids also it makes supporting the less popular elements of government spending harder.
- Zak 13y agoSlippery slope. Assuming, for the moment that it is a good idea to fund the highway system primarily or exclusively with taxes that approximate user fees, that does not imply that it necessarily makes sense to pay for education the same way. Nearly everyone who derives benefit from the highway system, directly or indirectly helps pay the tax, directly or indirectly. Higher fuel taxes would translate directly to higher prices for goods and services that use the highway system. Other things supported by taxation may be different - education, for example. There's reason to believe that having a well educated population is good for everyone who lives in the society, even people who are not, at that time receiving education. User fees are contrary to the goal of educating as many people to a certain level as possible, so a different model probably works better. it makes supporting the less popular elements of government spending harder Well, in a government that's more or less democratic, implementing less popular policies should be harder than implementing popular ones. That's kind of the point.
- walshemj 13y agoThat is the tryany of the majority as John Adams described it and even hard core libertarians agree that it is a bad thing.
- Zak 13y agoThe tyranny of the majority is the implementation of policy that is popular and tyrannical toward some unpopular minority. It's generally used as a justification for limits on government power, separation of powers and enumeration of specific rights in a constitution that is difficult to amend. Are you arguing that a policy's popularity should have no bearing on how difficult it is to enact and implement? That seems fundamentally incompatible with the idea of democratic government. Do you disagree, or would you like to advocate another form of government? As a side note, John Adams was anything but a hardcore libertarian.
- protomyth 13y agoI agree on raising the gas tax. They also need to start thinking about the gas tax equivalent for electric vehicles. A pay once a year (or even monthly) mileage tax is extremely punitive on poor folks. The tax at the pump works the same way as withholding for income taxes. It allows management in chunks of a tax the can get very high.
- 100k 13y agoAgreed. This is a solution to a non-problem. The usual argument is that with electrics and hybrids, tax revenue is going down. OK, fine, raise the rate! Plenty of people are still driving internal combustion vehicles. Higher rates will spur adoption of more efficient vehicles, which is a good thing. If we really want to charge by the mile, add an odometer reading to the smog check. There's no need for a complicated and privacy-invasive system to check how many miles you drive.
- greenyoda 13y ago"The usual argument is that with electrics and hybrids, tax revenue is going down." Electricity is also taxed quite heavily, so you aren't going to avoid all taxes by driving an electric or hybrid car.
- TwiztidK 13y agoI believe part of the issue is that as hybrids and electric vehicles become more popular, they won't be contributing anything for their road use so we do need to seek alternative means of taxing vehicles. I think the simplest method would be to implement some system of yearly odometer reading as it's low-tech, low-cost, and non-invasive.
- jws 13y agoThe wear caused on a road surface is a higher-than-linear function of axle loading. The standard model has a power of 4. Double the mass, 16 times the wear. Very light vehicles, like EVs, don't significantly wear the roads compared to large cars, pickups, and especially commercial trucks. Consider, (damage is normalized to a Ford F-150). Weight Damage Gallons/mile Honda Civic 2815 0.05 0.032 Toyota Prius 2921 0.05 0.020 Nissan Leaf 3291 0.09 Ford Transit Connect (me) 3500 0.11 0.50 Tesla Model S 4647 0.35 Ford F-150 Pickup 6000 1.0 0.059 Ford Excursion Diesel (bro) 7725 2.75 0.055 Maximum Loaded Truck 20000/axle 1970. (+other axles) 0.2 The Leaf does so little damage that we can ignore it. A Honda Civic weighs even less, but will be paying something like half what a pickup does for 1/20th of the damage. My brother's Excursion is doing about 25 times the road damage as my Connect, but we pay essentially the same gas tax. A truck with a maximally loaded axle is doing almost 2000 times the damage, for about 4 times the fuel tax. Clearly, fuel use as a proxy for road damage is flawed, but not because the light vehicles are getting away, more because the heavy vehicles are under paying. That exponent of four gets big in a hurry. I propose: Assess road expenses into wear based maintenance, and all other costs. Then each vehicle pays based on their mileage and "wear factor" for wear based maintenance and just their mileage for the rest of the costs. The black boxes are needed in the US because our roads are paid for locally, you have to break out the payments to the right parties. It's not like we aren't tracked everywhere we go anyway. Keep the fuel tax as a carbon tax, import/trade balance deterrent, revenue source. Edit: That proposal is going to need a rural subsidy, and possibly a freezing climate subsidy as well. By then it will get political and we'll probably end up with a tax on paint color by the time it is done.
- jws 13y agoTime and position based taxation could separate maintenance costs from "increased capacity" costs. If you tax peak drive time traffic higher, you could shift people to other patterns and not require more lanes to be added to urban highways. This can't be accomplished with a gas tax. (I used to never leave work between 4pm and 6:30pm to avoid my congested outer loop, I could have avoided tax on the unending parade of new lanes added over the past decade. If more people had joined me we could have saved quite a bit in construction costs.) Gas consumption and road wear is at least correlated in the right direction, typically, but you could also do a more accurate job of accurately taxing for road wear by combining vehicle type, road type, and mileage.
- chiph 13y agoWith the new CAFE mileage goals, tax revenue will fall as cars become more fuel efficient. Or as people buy more electric vehicles. The deal is that cars actually cause very little damage to the roads. Trucks are the real cause of road damage -- up to 80,000 pounds spread over five axles. Compare that to 4,000 pounds over two axles for a car (or 5-6k pounds for a loaded pickup or SUV) -- the per-axle weight is much higher for a truck. The trucking lobby is very powerful in Washington, and will resist any effort to increase the diesel motor-fuels tax. They have a powerful argument in their favor: The majority of food in America is delivered by truck. Raise the tax, raise the cost of food. But even outside of that, there's a simple way to get about a 20% increase in funds for repairing the roads & bridges, and that's to stop the diversion of funds out of the highway trust fund into the general fund. The tax money intended to go to build & maintain our crumbling transportation infrastructure, is instead being fed into the sausage factory where it gets turned into pork.
- PeterisP 13y agoThe valid argument for not taxing a flat rate ($xxx per car per year) is that it unfairly penalizes those who use it very little. For personal vehicles that makes sense, so their 'costs' are mostly paid by the gas excise; but for commercial trucks you can just tax them directly - for example, here local semi-trailers pay ~$350 annual vehicle tax; does USA have something like this? The food argument is bullshit, of course, but probably effective because it sounds nice. The truck fuel cost is a very tiny part of the actual food cost - taxes on farming fuel would impact food, but not that. Of course, extra taxes always create inflation; but fuel tax is probably the one most evenly spread across everything, as it affects burger prices just the same as Barbie prices.
- chiph 13y agoThe federal diesel motor fuels tax is 28¢ per gallon. The states will have their own tax as well. Texas imposes a 20¢ per gallon tax. Connecticut's is 54.9¢. There's also a tax on the vehicle itself. I want to say that it's in the $500 per year range, depending on it's GVWR and the state.
- msandford 13y ago
- Tiktaalik 13y agoElectric cars degrade the road at the same rate as gasoline cars and we'll need to keep the funding for road maintenance at the same level as more and more people move to electric cars.
- protomyth 13y agoThen make it very simple for adoption, tax the electricity like we tax gas. Do not come up with some new system just figure out the rough equivalent and put a tax on it.
- michaelt 13y agoWhy is raising the gas tax not an option? It is an option. You are currently witnessing an attempt to move the Overton Window [1] from "should we or should we not raise the gas tax" to "should we raise the gas tax or should we add a mileage tax with big brother tracking". Later legislators will tell us they've listened to us, and they're going to raise the gas tax instead of instituting a mileage tax. There will be much rejoicing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window