2 ms·
A good post although I suggest rephrasing "useful" to something like "experimentally falsifiable". With a pretty wide definition of "experimentally" and "world
by VLM 13y ago
A good post although I suggest rephrasing "useful" to something like "experimentally falsifiable". With a pretty wide definition of "experimentally" and "world", especially for non-applied math.
If you have no way to do a falsifiable test, and can't just substitute in a X and do abstract analysis of X instead of worrying about X, then its just a belief.
I'd be careful categorizing stuff eternally as beliefs not axioms. Blindly only permitting geometry to be Euclidean meant some exciting non-euclidean results couldn't happen until it was "allowed" to be thought about somewhat recently (well, a century or two ago...). Also physicists have this amazing ability to turn pure math into applied math, at least over a long enough historical scale. And physicists have a pretty good ability at coming up with crazy experimental methods to test, look at the last 75 yrs or so of quantum physics... so let me get this straight, you do what with two geiger counters and a truly giant magnet and some radioactive atoms or what? Or shine a light beam or ion beam thru that weird magnet?