11 ms·
It's still a huge slap in the face to those who's been using Pages for anything even slightly complicated. I'm an author. I wrote my books in Pages, loved it,
by graeme 13y ago
It's still a huge slap in the face to those who's been using Pages for anything even slightly complicated.
I'm an author. I wrote my books in Pages, loved it, and recommended it to everyone. I'm now very glad I didn't upgrade, because Pages 5 would make it impossible to format my books.
I'm the sort of guy who tells everyone he knows "buy a Mac!". I'm now hesitant, for the first time in a long while. I'm very concerned about iOS-ification. I bought this machine because I use it to do things.
This happened in 2011 with Final Cut Pro. Apple lost a lot of video editors, and my understanding is that their mindshare didn't bounce back.
- ghshephard 13y ago"I'm the sort of guy who tells everyone he knows "buy a Mac!". I'm now hesitant, for the first time in a long while. " You can still buy a Mac and use Office (MS Excel best spreadsheet on the planet), or Scrivener, etc... Apple is distracted (perhaps correctly so) by the MASSIVE revenue/profit stream that is iOS. The Software revenue for the Mac is minuscule in comparison. All of their attention/energy will be pouring gasoline on the iOS platform, possibly to the exclusion of everything else. The good news is we can ignore the Apps that Apple is churning out, and use the ones that make sense for us. I'm a 4+ year Aperture user who probably is going to have to bite the bullet and shift to Lightroom (perhaps 2 years later than I should). On the pro-side, nobody in business was using the Numbers product, so they aren't in any way impacted by the iWork news. I do feel for those who used Pages (I actually know quite a few who preferred it to Word) - but, the old version of Pages still works, even after Upgrade, and, eventually, the Pages product will start to move forward again as the iOS platform evolves. Overall rational and profit seeking move by Apple, even if it does screw a lot of their power users.
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoApple would rather you write a book in iBooks Author than anything else. Pages and MS Word have never really been products for the professional author: they are consumer-class apps for the mass-market. Apple recognises this to a greater extent than Microsoft, and by cutting functionality, they can vastly improve usability for the core market. Whether they will bother to fill the void left with their own professional writing software or not is up for debate; they will, IMO, just leave that to Adobe. I think you should still tell everyone you know to buy a Mac. Just tell those who are professional-class writers that the latest version of Pages might not fulfil their needs and point out the alternatives.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoAlso, if he wants to make his publisher happy, he should write in Adobe InCopy. http://www.adobe.com/products/incopy.html http://www.adobe.com/products/incopy.html
- Samuel_Michon 13y ago> This happened in 2011 with Final Cut Pro. Apple lost a lot of video editors, and my understanding is that their mindshare didn't bounce back. That’s a myth. Out of the 100 editors I know only 2 left for Premiere, and they would’ve gone regardless of what Apple did. Others were already only using Avid, they never switched the Final Cut. The actual users of Final Cut 7 continued to use FCP7 or waited to switch to FCP X when it had all the features they needed. Right now, in my experience, about three quarters of those people have switched to FCP X, and I hear nothing but positive stories about it.
- graeme 13y agoAh, interesting. Do you have any stats on this? I was just going on anecdotes from news articles.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoI don’t think there are any general stats on what video editing professionals use, as they work in a lot of different fields. Big budget motion picture editors have always used Avid and most will continue to do so – MPEG and ACE stats are therefore not very relevant. Some indies shoot with RED, ARRI Alexa, or HDSLRs – many of them do use FCP. FCP is more popular with ad agencies, TV production companies, documentary filmmakers, and education. On the online community for documentary filmmakers, The D-Word, the software most frequently mentioned is FCP. The same can be witnessed on 5dplanet, a forum for freelancers and indies who shoot with HDSLRs. Also telling: the comments on an article[1] about switching from FCP to PP; all of the commenters indicate they won’t fully switch to PP. That article is at a very popular site for indie filmmakers. Even Cinema Editor Magazine (the ACE quarterly) wrote in its latest review of PP: “Premiere Pro doesn’t seem quite ready for a multi-editor, multi-camera, scripted series or feature.”[2]. This is all circumstantial evidence, but combined with my own experiences and what I have seen and heard from colleagues, I am pretty confident that the number of people who left FCP after the release of FCP X is minimal. Now, that’s not to say those people don’t also have PP – I have PP, but that’s because it comes with Adobe Creative Cloud, not because I chose it. In my experience, the people who switched from FCP to PP or Avid did so because they wanted to use Windows based computers. Remember that Apple has neglected its Pro line of desktops for quite some time. Xserves are gone, the Mac Pro hasn’t been updated in years – until the new Mac Pro announcement earlier this year, many professionals considered switching to Windows workstations. [1] http://nofilmschool.com/2011/07/import-final-cut-pro-7-project-adobe-premiere/ http://nofilmschool.com/2011/07/import-final-cut-pro-7-proje... [2] http://www.cinemaeditormagazine.com/ http://www.cinemaeditormagazine.com/