2 ms·
It doesn't matter if the facts are about reality or fiction. If I say 'There are 1234 notes in that Beatles song, and C-F-G-C chords are often seen there' then
by PeterisP 13y ago
It doesn't matter if the facts are about reality or fiction. If I say 'There are 1234 notes in that Beatles song, and C-F-G-C chords are often seen there' then it doesn't matter that the song is product of a human's creative work, the facts are not that creative work.
If I say 'hobbits in Tolkien's work have hairy feet' then again, Tolkien made that fact up, it didn't exist before his writing, but it's still not copyrighted or 'copyrightable'.
Copyright is about copying the actual prose or drawings from Pokemon, but stating the facts about that prose or drawings is allowed.
- nkuttler 13y ago"Name Charizard, Types fire/flying, electric 2x rock 4x water 2x" etc. don't at all sound like "facts" to me. They seem to be the core of an individual pokemon, they are what makes that pokemon a unique creative work. This sounds more like publishing the chords of a song, it's melody and lyrics, but not using the cover art. Anyway, the fact that there's even a discussion about this is proof enough that apple did good to reject the app. It's not apple's job to have a team of lawyers review apps with regard to the intricacies of copyright law.