3 ms·
You can only do this if the trader agrees to stay at the firm over the long term, or perhaps if he is a daytrader. Using your scheme, a trader simply will not
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
You can only do this if the trader agrees to stay at the firm over the long term, or perhaps if he is a daytrader.
Using your scheme, a trader simply will not enter into a contract with a great chance of long term gain and short term fluctuations. Short term fluctuations may eat up his pay, even if the long term gain is guaranteed.
- Retric 17y agoPlenty of people are willing to do startups for low base pay with the hope of a high reward. The real issue is you can't really beat the market just change your level of risk. So the real focus in investment banking is hiding risks in ever more creative ways.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI think you are overestimating the number of people willing to do startups. As for beating the market, you certainly can. Plenty of people do it -- every successful startup founder, for instance. You can also hedge risks, which is not hiding risk but paying someone else to assume them. This creates value: you focus on your core competency (your business) and someone else focuses on their core competency (managing risk). Furthermore, even those who don't beat the market are contributing to raising the market average. I.e., if you didn't have a bunch of people trying to beat an average market return of 4%, then the average return would be lower (e.g. 2%).
- Retric 17y agoROI decreases as more money is invested in the market. Also as an investor, beating the market is not simply ending up with more money. I can go to Vegas with 1000$ bet on black and have a 48% chance to look like I "beat the market" but I could have also lost money. You can change the type of risk you are talking in roulette but a 90% chance of winning 1000$ involves a ~10% chance of losing 10,000$. This still sums to a negative number even if it looks like a great bet most of the time. Investing is normally a positive return over time. But, if you are willing to lose a lot of money 5% of the time you can probably make it look like you invested well. The risk is still there, but it normally looks like you are "beating the market" even though you are just placing bets. (This ignores actually producing a product or exploiting insider information. It also ignores scams where you take a tiny risk to lose more money than you have.) PS: Hedging also has a cost and the net effect is a loss.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou can't ignore producing a product. The purpose of financial markets is to provide liquidity, hedging and information to people actually producing products. The financial markets tell us that GM deserves no further capital while Apple does. This increases market returns by allocating resources towards productive investments and away from bad ones. As for ROI decreasing as more money is invested, so what? As more money is invested in the market, it chases more marginal investments. Thus, total returns / total invested goes down. What's your point? Incidentally, hedging has a cost. That's not the same as saying the net effect is a loss. By that logic, all trade is a net loss due to transaction costs. Like all trade, hedging exploits comparative advantage. If I have a comparative advantage in making widgets and you have one in risk management, and our comparative advantages exceed transaction costs, we have a net gain.