5 ms·
FB is the 21st century equivalent of the market square No, it isn't. The Internet as a whole might be, but FB isn't. It's the equivalent of a particular shop t
by pdonis 13y ago
FB is the 21st century equivalent of the market square
No, it isn't. The Internet as a whole might be, but FB isn't. It's the equivalent of a particular shop that happens to be contiguous to the market square, but is still private property.
1st amendment should prohibit what they are trying to do
The 1st amendment gives you the right of free speech, but it does not give you the right to commandeer someone else's resources for that purpose. FB does not belong to you, or to the public. If FB decides to block you from using their site, for whatever reason, then you just have to go exercise your right of free speech somewhere else.
- emiliobumachar 13y agoI agree with what you said, but not with how it seems to answer your parent comment. If tax money pays for 2 minutes worth of labor by a police officer to log into watever tool and click a button to ban an account, then it's no longer a generic case of FB deciding to block an account "for watever reason". I'm not saying it should never happen, I'm saying it should be subject to due process. Disclosure: non-American with cursory knowledge of American law.
- pdonis 13y agoIf tax money pays for 2 minutes worth of labor by a police officer to log into watever tool and click a button to ban an account, then it's no longer a generic case of FB deciding to block an account "for watever reason". True; but it's still not a case of the account holder's free speech rights being infringed, because the account holder doesn't have a free speech right to use FB's resources in the first place. If the police were trying to keep him from posting to his own blog on a domain that he owned himself, that would be different. This kind of thing might be an instance of infringing Facebook's rights to manage their property how they want, if FB was being forced to give the police officer access; but that doesn't appear to be the case: FB appears to be cooperating voluntarily with law enforcement to provide this tool. I'm not saying it should never happen, I'm saying it should be subject to due process. I don't disagree, but the reason for requiring due process would not be to protect free speech rights for FB's users; it would be because US citizens decide, collectively, that we don't want to allow the police to have this kind of power without more oversight, even if a private company like Facebook provides the access voluntarily. I'm not sure what, if any, Constitutional provision that invokes, but I don't think it's the 1st Amendment.
- declan 13y ago"It's still not a case of the New York Times' free speech rights being infringed, because the New York Times does not have a free speech right to use a third party's printing presses to publish newspapers. If the police were trying to keep the New York Times from publishing using its own printing presses, that would be different." I took the liberty of rephrasing the parent comment to target dead tree media. The First Amendment problems with such an order to a third-party printer are left as an exercise for the first year law student. That is not to say it's always a slam dunk case; there's a continuum between "FYI Facebook," "Please ban," and "Here's a formal order to ban."
- pdonis 13y agothe New York Times does not have a free speech right to use a third party's printing presses to publish newspapers Isn't this correct? Can't a third party refuse to let the NYT use its printers? The First Amendment problems with such an order to a third-party printer As I said in the post you responded to, AFAIK the government is not issuing an "order" to Facebook; Facebook is voluntarily allowing the police to do this. If FB was being "ordered" to do this, that would be different. But as I said in the post you responded to, I still don't think it would be a First Amendment issue; it would be a private property issue (the government trying to restrict how Facebook can make decisions about its property, namely who can use its services).
- declan 13y agoThis is an area where your instincts may say X, but modern First Amendment jurisprudence says !X. The 1A protects expression from state action and comes close, in modern jurisprudence, to prohibiting prior restraint including an order to kill or suspend a FB account. It's clear that some degree of state action pressure on intermediaries (publishers, FB, web sites) is illegal and unconstitutional; I was responding to your point that I read as arguing the contrary in all cases. Whether a particular state action crosses the 1A line is a fact-dependent analysis -- some of the examples in this rather vague article strike me as falling on the wrong side of that line. Also note that some state constitutions, including California's, have free speech protections that go beyond the federal 1A.
- nitrogen 13y agoNo, it isn't. The Internet as a whole might be, but FB isn't. It's the equivalent of a particular shop that happens to be contiguous to the market square, but is still private property. The telephone network was also largely private property, but its use was deemed important and ubiquitous enough that telephone companies were required to act as common carriers. The modern "walled garden" web sites are becoming the only place where one can reliably communicate with all of their friends and family, and thus the only opportunity one has to exercise their free speech rights. Facebook, essentially, should belong to the public inasmuch as Facebook strives to become indispensable to the public.
- gscott 13y agoThe CEO of Facebook goes as far as saying he wants it to be a utility: http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/facebook-the-social-web-utility-company/5152 http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/facebook-the-social-web-utilit...
- pdonis 13y agoYes, back in 2007, and on the basis of exposing various API functions that FB has now repeatedly shown that it is willing to arbitrarily restrict or revoke when developers use them in ways FB doesn't like. They are within their rights to do that, but it's not the sort of behavior that's consistent with wanting to be a utility. But even if FB didn't do that, the argument about them being a utility doesn't hold water, because, as nknighthb pointed out upthread, FB could shut down tomorrow and people would simply find other means of social networking. The public utility is the Internet infrastructure itself; that is what would cause huge disruption if it were suddenly shut down or restricted.
- pdonis 13y agoThe telephone network was also largely private property, but its use was deemed important and ubiquitous enough that telephone companies were required to act as common carriers. See nknighthb's comment on this upthread. The modern "walled garden" web sites are becoming the only place where one can reliably communicate with all of their friends and family You're kidding, right? Haven't you heard of email? What you mean is, the "walled garden" web sites are more convenient ways for lots of people to communicate with friends and family. Convenience is not enough to invoke free speech rights. and thus the only opportunity one has to exercise their free speech rights Huh? There are plenty of sites where you can start a blog for free. Web hosting is cheap. And even if you leave all that out, what do you think you're doing by commenting here?